_Schöne’s Elutriator_ is the one commonly used in Europe; in it the upward current ascends in a conical glass tube, (see figure 6) entering through a narrow, curved inlet tube, in which the soil sample is kept agitated by the current itself. The objection to this plan is twofold: first, the narrow, curved inlet-tube is readily clogged by the soil mass at the lower velocities, which are thereby changed, so that, unless a very small amount of soil only is employed, the whole mass is not kept properly stirred; second, the circulating currents brought about by the conical shape of the tube cause the sediment-particles to coalesce into complex, larger ones (floccules), which will then settle down and fail to pass over at the current-velocity corresponding to their individual component parts. [Illustration: FIG. 7.—The Churn Elutriator (Hilgard’s) for the physical analysis of soils.] _Churn Elutriator with Cylindrical Tube._—The errors just alluded to are obviated by an arrangement devised by the writer, in which a rapidly revolving stirrer, placed at the base of a cylindrical tube in which the washing process is conducted and which eliminates counter-currents, continually disintegrates these compound particles, and thus enables the entire quantity of the sediment corresponding to the prevailing current-velocity to pass off with a comparatively slight expenditure of time on the part of the operator (see figure 7). A wire screen interposed between the churn and cylindrical glass tube prevents communication of the whirling motion to the column. As the apparatus works automatically, the analyst has only to observe from time to time whether or not the turbidity near the top of the tube has disappeared; and as the sediment accumulates at the bottom of the tall receiver bottle,[25] no harm is done if the attendant should neglect to change the velocity in time, except that water will run to waste. [25] The figure given of this elutriator in Bulletin No. 24, on physical soil analysis, published by the U. S. Bureau of Soils, shows as the receiver a bottle entirely too low to insure the complete retention of the sediments by settling. The receiving bottle should not be less than twelve inches high and five inches wide. The conical relay glass below the churn serves to retain the coarser grades of sediments which are not concerned in the velocities employed in the elutriator tube, and thus prevents injurious attrition. But these sediments can at any time be stirred up by the incoming current and brought into the washing tube if desired. In the same manner the passing-off of the finer sediments can be materially accelerated by running off rapidly about two-thirds of the turbid column of water every twenty minutes. It should be fully understood that prior to attempting such separation, the “colloidal clay” must first be removed by the subsidence or centrifugal method, since otherwise much larger grain-sizes may be carried off at a given velocity.