Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
When X was about 7 years old, the matter of his difficulties was first
taken up, with the family physician, who said he would “grow out of it
and be all right.” As years passed, and the child continued to be
untaught, the physician finally advised the visit to the Neurological
Institute.
The teacher’s opinion was that the boy must be feeble-minded, since five
different teachers had tried to instruct him in reading and spelling,
yet he had failed to read or spell any word, except his name. He could
recognize his name among other words, and could _draw_ it fairly well,
much as he would draw a house or tree. He could not _spell_ his name.
Vision and audition had been tested at the Manhattan Eye and Ear
Infirmary, and the report was that no significant defect of eye or ear
existed. Motor tests showed the boy to be right-handed, so that
interference in word-management, possibly due to change in “handedness,”
was eliminated.
The developmental history of X as an organism reveals nothing atypical,
except defects of speech and difficulty in reading. He was born
normally, walked and talked before he was two years old, and was normal
in dentition. But he did not _talk plainly_ till he was about 6 years
old. He had a speech defect, stuttered, and could not say “l”.
His medical history shows that he had whooping cough as a baby; that
tonsils and adenoids were removed at the age of 5 years; that he had an
abscess in the left ear at the age of 4 years, which lasted about two
weeks, but did not impair hearing; that he had diphtheria at the age of
11 years, a bad case, followed by temporary paralysis of the soft
palate; that he had never had any convulsion or loss of consciousness;
that he had never had chorea, or other disease of the nervous system.
Physically he was well developed, measurements on February 14, 1918,
being as follows: Standing height, 59.8 inches; sitting height, 29.6
inches; weight (with ordinary clothing on), 86¼ pounds; cranial
circumference, 21.2 inches; right grip (Smedley), 20 Kg.; left grip, 18
Kg.; lung capacity (wet spirometer), 130 cubic inches.
As for family history, X is the youngest of four siblings, all others of
whom learned without difficulty to read and spell. His sister graduated
from high school with a state scholarship, went through college, and is
now a teacher in a high school. An older brother graduated from the
elementary school at 14 years, in spite of the fact that he missed two
semesters through illness. He also had a speech defect “about the same
as X,” but outgrew it. Another brother had reached 8B by the time he was
13 years old. Of thirteen cousins attending school, only one had ever
been “left back.”
The mother had graduated at the usual age from common school. The father
had been troubled in boyhood by a speech defect, which disappeared. “He
could not say certain words and letters.” On this account he did not
like school. As an adult he reads the newspapers, and “can write a
straight letter.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account