Monstrosities are often considered as accidents, and rightfully so, at
least as long as they are considered from a morphological point of view.
Physiology of course excludes all accidentality. And in our present ease
it shows [401] that some internal hereditary quality is present, though
often latent, and that the observed anomalies are to be regarded as
responses of this innate tendency to external conditions. Our two types
differ in the frequency of these responses. Rare in the poor race, they
are numerous in the rich variety. The external conditions being the same
for both, the hereditary factor must be different. The tendency is weak
in the one and strong in the other. In both cases, according to my
experience, it may be weakened or strengthened by selection and by
treatment. Often to a very remarkable degree, but not so far as to
transgress the limits between the two races. Such transgression may
apparently be met with from time to time, but then the next generation
generally shows the fallacy of the conclusion, as it returns more or
less directly to the type from which the strain had been derived.
Monstrosities should always be studied by physiologists from this point
of view. Poor and rich strains of the same anomaly seem at first sight
to be so nearly allied that it might be thought to be very easy to
change the one into the other. Nevertheless such changes are not on
record, and although I have made several attempts in this line, I never
succeeded in passing the limit. I am quite convinced that sometime [402]
a method will be discovered of arbitrarily producing such conversions,
and perhaps the easiest way to attain artificial mutations may lie
concealed here. But as yet not the slightest indication of this
possibility is to be found, save the fallacious conclusions drawn from
too superficial observations.
Unfortunately the poor strains are not very interesting. Their chance of
producing beautiful instances of the anomaly for which they are
cultivated is too small. Exceptions to this rule are only afforded by
those curious and rare anomalies, which command general attention, and
of which, therefore, instances are always welcome. In such cases they
are searched for with perseverance, and the fact of their rarity
impresses itself strongly on our mind.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account