Until recently I have felt that there was a serious (or, if you like,
a comic) difficulty about the ultimate fate of the white dwarfs.
Their high density is only possible because of the smashing of the
atoms, which in turn depends on the high temperature. It does not seem
permissible to suppose that the matter can remain in this compressed
state if the temperature falls. We may look forward to a time when the
supply of subatomic energy fails and there is nothing to maintain the
high temperature; then on cooling down, the material will return to
the normal density of terrestrial solids. The star must, therefore,
expand, and in order to regain a density a thousandfold less the radius
must expand tenfold. Energy will be required in order to force out
the material against gravity. Where is this energy to come from? An
ordinary star has not enough heat energy inside it to be able to expand
against gravitation to this extent; and the white dwarf can scarcely be
supposed to have had sufficient foresight to make special provision for
this remote demand. Thus the star may be in an awkward predicament--it
will be losing heat continually _but will not have enough energy to
cool down_.
One suggestion for avoiding this dilemma is like the device of a
novelist who brings his characters into such a mess that the only
solution is to kill them off. We might assume that subatomic energy
will never cease to be liberated until it has removed the whole
mass--or at least conducted the star out of the white dwarf condition.
But this scarcely meets the difficulty; the theory ought in some way to
guard automatically against an impossible predicament, and not to rely
on disconnected properties of matter to protect the actual stars from
trouble.
The whole difficulty seems, however, to have been removed in a recent
investigation by R. H. Fowler. He concludes unexpectedly that the
dense matter of the Companion of Sirius has an ample store of energy
to provide for the expansion. The interesting point is that his
solution invokes some of the most recent developments of the quantum
theory--the ‘new statistics’ of Einstein and Bose and the wave-theory
of Schrödinger. It is a curious coincidence that about the time that
this matter of transcendently high density was engaging the attention
of astronomers, the physicists were developing a new theory of matter
which specially concerns high density. According to this theory matter
has certain wave properties which barely come into play at terrestrial
densities; but they are of serious importance at densities such as that
of the Companion of Sirius. It was in considering these properties
that Fowler came upon the store of energy that solves our difficulty;
the classical theory of matter gives no indication of it. The white
dwarf appears to be a happy hunting ground for the most revolutionary
developments of theoretical physics.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account