Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
It would be tedious to draw out the parallel: given similar social
conditions in America we have not been able to escape the same social
results, even down to the fact that the palliatives of private
philanthropy flourish here again as they had not flourished anywhere on
the same scale since the Roman Empire. So much for imperial greatness.
When an architect like Mr. Edward Bennett can say, as he did in The
Significance of the Fine Arts: “House the people densely, if necessary,
but conserve great areas for recreation,” we need not be in doubt as to
who will profit by the density and who will profit, at the other end,
by the recreation. It is not merely that the park must be produced
to remedy the congestion: it is even more that the congestion must
be produced in order to provide for the park. To profit by both the
disease and the remedy is one of the master-strokes of imperialist
enterprise. Mr. Daniel Burnham said of the World’s Fair, according to
Mr. Bennett and Mr. Charles Moore, “that it is what the Romans would
have wished to create in permanent form.” One may say of our imperial
cities that they are what the Romans did create--but whether the form
will be permanent or not is a matter we may leave to the sardonic
attentions of history.
For my own part, I think we have at last acquired a criterion which
will enable us to sum up the architecture of the imperial age, and
deal justly with these railroad stations and stadiums, these sewers
and circuses, these aqueducts and parkways and grand avenues. Our
imperial architecture is an architecture of compensation: it provides
grandiloquent stones for people who have been deprived of bread
and sunlight and all that keeps man from becoming vile. Behind the
monumental façades of our metropolises trudges a landless proletariat,
doomed to the servile routine of the factory system; and beyond the
great cities lies a countryside whose goods are drained away, whose
children are uprooted from the soil on the prospect of easy gain and
endless amusements, and whose remaining cultivators are steadily
drifting into the ranks of an abject tenantry. This is not a casual
observation: it is the translation of the last three census reports
into plain English. Can one take the pretensions of this architecture
seriously; can one worry about its esthetics or take full delight
in such finer forms as Mr. Pope’s Temple of the Scottish Rite in
Washington, or Mr. Bacon’s Lincoln Memorial? Yes, perhaps--if one
refuses to look beyond the mask.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account