Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
Even in some of its proudest buildings, the imperial show wears thin;
and one need not peer into the slums beyond in order to realize its
defects. The rear of the Metropolitan Museum or the Brooklyn Museum,
for example, might be the rear of a row of Bronx tenements or Long
Island City factories, so gaunt and barren and hideous is their
aspect. If the imperial age was foreshadowed in the World’s Fair, it
has received its apotheosis in the museum. In contrast to the local
museums one still finds occasionally in Europe, which are little more
than extensions of the local curio cabinet, the imperial museum is
essentially a loot-heap, a comprehensive repository for plunder. The
sage Viollet-le-Duc once patly said that he preferred to see his apples
hanging on a tree, rather than arranged in rows in the fruit shop: but
the animus of the museum is to value the plucked fruit more than the
tree that bore it.
Into the museum come the disjecta membra of other lands, other
cultures, other civilizations. All that had once been a living faith
and practice is here reduced to a separate specimen, pattern, or form.
For the museum, the world of art has already been created: the future
is restricted to a duplication of the perfected past. This animus is
identic with that which made the Romans so skillful in copying Greek
statues and so dull in carving their own; a desirable habit of humility
were it not for the fact that the works of art in the past could not
have been created had our ancestors been so punctual in respect to
finished designs. The one thing the museum cannot attempt to do is to
supply a soil for living art: all that it can present is a pattern
for reproduction. To the extent that an insincere or imitative art is
better than no art at all, the Imperial Age marked an advance: to the
extent, however, that a living art is a fresh gesture of the spirit,
the museum confessed all too plainly that the age had no fresh gestures
to make; on that score, it was a failure, and the copying of period
furniture and the design of period architecture were the livid proofs
of that failure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account