Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
The processes which are inimical to architecture are, perhaps, seen
at their worst in the business district of the metropolis; but more
and more they tend to spread throughout the rest of the community. Mr.
Charles McKim, for example, was enthusiastic over Mr. Burnham’s design
for the Illinois Trust and Savings Bank in Chicago, and predicted that
it would long be a monument to his genius. “But unfortunately,” as Mr.
Burnham’s biographer says, “unfortunately for Mr. McKim’s reputation
as a prophet, he was unappreciative of the rapid growth of Chicago,
the consequent appreciation in the value of real estate in the Loop
district, and the expansive force of a great bank. This beautiful
building is doomed to be replaced by one which will tower into the
air to the permissible height of structures in the business section
of Chicago.” The alternative to this destruction is an even more
ignominious state of preservation; such a state as the Knickerbocker
Trust Company building achieved in New York, or the old Customs
House in Boston, both of which have been smothered under irrelevant
skyscrapers. Even where economic necessity plays no distinct part,
the forms of business take precedence over the forms of humanism--as
in the Shipping Board’s York Village, where as soon as the direction
of the community planner was removed a hideous and illiterate row of
shop-fronts was erected, instead of that provided by the architect, in
spite of the fact that the difference in cost was negligible.
Unfortunately for architecture, every district of the modern city
tends to become a business district, in the sense that its development
takes place less in response to direct human needs than to the chances
and exigencies of sale. It is not merely business buildings that are
affected by the inherent instability of enterprises to which profit
and rent have become Ideal Ends: the same thing is happening to the
great mass of houses and apartments which are designed for sale.
Scarcely any element in our architecture and city planning is free
from the encroachment, direct or indirect, of business enterprise.
The old Boulevard in New York, for example, which was laid out by the
Tweed ring long before the land on either side was used for anything
but squatters’ farms, was almost totally disrupted by the building
of the first subways, and it has taken twenty years to effect even a
partial recovery. The widening of part of Park Avenue by slicing off
its central grass plot has just been accomplished, in order to relieve
traffic congestion; and it needs only a little time before underground
and overground traffic will cause the gradual reduction of our other
parkways--even those which now seem secure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account