Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
All this would perhaps seem a little fantastic, were it not for the
fact that we have step by step approached the reality. Except for our
old-fashioned prejudice in favor of windows, which holds over from a
time when one could see a green field or a passing neighbor by sitting
at one, the transformation favored by the engineers has already been
accomplished. Just because of the ease in installing fans, lights,
and radiators in a modern building, a good part of the interiors
of our skyscrapers are fed day and night with artificial light and
ventilation. The margin of misuse under this method of construction
is necessarily great; the province of design, limited. Instead of the
architect’s paying attention to exposure, natural circulation, and
direct daylight, and making a layout which will achieve these necessary
ends, he is forced to center his efforts on the maximum exploitation
of land. Where the natural factors are flouted or neglected, the
engineer is always ready to provide a mechanical substitute--“just as
good as the original” and much more expensive.
By systematically neglecting the simplest elements of city planning,
we have provided a large and profitable field for all the palliative
devices of engineering: where we eliminate sunlight we introduce
electric light; where we congest business, we build skyscrapers; where
we overcrowd the thoroughfares with traffic we burrow subways; where
we permit the city to become congested with a population whose density
would not be tolerated in a well-designed community, we conduct water
hundreds of miles by aqueducts to bathe them and slake their thirst;
where we rob them of the faintest trace of vegetation or fresh air, we
build metalled roads which will take a small portion of them, once a
week, out into the countryside. It is all a very profitable business
for the companies that supply light and rapid transit and motor
cars, and the rest of it; but the underlying population pays for its
improvements both ways--that is, it stands the gratuitous loss, and it
pays “through the nose” for the remedy.
These mechanical improvements, these labyrinths of subways, these
audacious towers, these endless miles of asphalted streets, do not
represent a triumph of human effort: they stand for its comprehensive
misapplication. Where an inventive age follows methods which have no
relation to an intelligent and humane existence, an imaginative one
would not be caught by the necessity. By turning our environment over
to the machine we have robbed the machine of the one promise it held
out--that of enabling us to humanize more thoroughly the details of our
existence.
III
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account