Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
Religion
Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
Medicine -- History; Science -- History
Faith need be kept with heretics and sorcerers ‘for a time only’.[292]
Therefore an inquisitor may promise not to condemn a person if he
confesses, and then pass sentence after a few days, or if of very
tender conscience by the mouth of another. It is also lawful to
introduce persons, _etiam mulieres honestae_, to the accused who
promise to find means for their escape if they will teach them some
form of witchcraft. This, say the authors, is a most successful method
for getting convictions.[293]
Torture, though it may not be repeated on the same charge, may be
continued as long as necessary, and any fresh evidence justifies a
repetition. Finally the accused may be burnt without confession if the
evidence is strong enough, or he may be kept in prison for months
or years, when the _squalor carceris_ may induce him to confess his
crimes.[294]
Such are the proceedings recommended against persons suspected of or
denounced for witchcraft, and they conclude appropriately with the
hideously hypocritical formula with which they were delivered over to
be burnt: ‘Relinquimus te potestati curiae secularis, deprecantes tamen
illam ut erga te citra sanguinis effusionem et mortis periculum suam
sententiam moderetur’,[295] which means, according to the _Malleus_,
that sorcerers are to be burned even though they repent, while
repentant heretics may be imprisoned for life.
What was meant by the _squalor carceris_ may be seen from the following
description by an eye-witness, Pretorius:[296]
‘Some [of the dungeons] are holes like cellars or wells, fifteen
to thirty fathoms (?) deep with openings above, through which they
let down the prisoners with ropes and draw them up when they will.
Such prisons I have seen myself. Some sit in great cold, so that
their feet are frost-bitten or frozen off, and afterwards, if they
escape, they are crippled for life. Some lie in continual darkness,
so that they never see a ray of sunlight, and know not whether it
be night or day. All of them have their limbs confined so that they
can hardly move, and are in continual unrest, and lie in their own
refuse, far more filthy and wretched than cattle. They are badly
fed, cannot sleep in peace, have much anxiety, heavy thoughts, bad
dreams. And since they cannot move hands or feet, they are plagued
and bitten by lice, rats, and other vermin, besides being daily
abused and threatened by gaolers and executioners. And since all
this sometimes lasts months or years, such persons, though at first
they be courageous, rational, strong, and patient, at length become
weak, timid, hopeless, and if not quite, at least half idiotic and
desperate.’
Yet all this was not considered torture, and if some poor wretch, after
a year of it, went mad, or preferred a quick death to a slow one, her
confession was described as being ‘entirely voluntary and without
torture’.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account