Studies in the South and West, with Comments on CanadaWarner, Charles Dudley
History
Studies in the South and West, with Comments on Canada
Warner, Charles Dudley
Canada -- Description and travel; United States -- Description and travel
We came at night to Harlan Court-house, an old shabby hamlet, but
growing and improving, having a new court-house and other signs of the
awakening of the people to the wealth here in timber and mines. Here in
a beautiful valley three streams—Poor, Martin, and Clover forks—unite to
form the Cumberland. The place has fourteen “stores” and three taverns,
the latter a trial to the traveller. Harlan has been one of the counties
most conspicuous for lawlessness. The trouble is not simply individual
wickedness, but the want of courage of public opinion, coupled with a
general disrespect for authority. Plenty of people lament the state of
things, but want the courage to take a public stand. The day before we
reached the Court-house the man who killed his wife and his brother
had his examination. His friends were able to take the case before a
friendly justice instead of the judge. The facts sworn to were that in a
drunken dispute over cards he tried to kill his son-in-law, who escaped
out of the window, and that his wife and brother opposed him, and he
killed them with his pistol. Therefore their deaths were accidental,
and he was discharged. Many people said privately that he ought to be
hanged, but there was entire public apathy over the affair. If Harlan
had three or four resolute men who would take a public stand that this
lawlessness must cease, they could carry the community with them. But
the difficulty of enforcing law and order in some of these mountain
counties is to find proper judges, prosecuting officers, and sheriffs.
The officers are as likely as not to be the worst men in the community,
and if they are not, they are likely to use their authority for
satisfying their private grudges and revenges. Consequently men take
the “law” into their own hands. The most personally courageous become
bullies and the terror of the community. The worst citizens are not
those who have killed most men, in the opinion of the public. It ought
to be said that in some of the mountain counties there has been very
little lawlessness, and in some it has been repressed by the local
authorities, and there is great improvement on the whole. I was sorry
not to meet a well-known character in the mountains, who has killed
twenty-one men. He is a very agreeable “square” man, and I believe
“high-toned,” and it is the universal testimony that he never killed a
man who did not deserve killing, and whose death was a benefit to the
community. He is called, in the language of the country, a “severe” man.
In a little company that assembled at the Harlan tavern were two elderly
men, who appeared to be on friendly terms enough. Their sons had had
a difficulty, and two boys out of each family had been killed not very
long ago. The fathers were not involved in the vendetta. About the old
Harlan court-house a great many men have been killed during court week
in the past few years. The habit of carrying pistols and knives, and
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account