A somewhat different case is that where the vivid fancy underlying the
misstatement may be supposed to lead to a measure of self-deception.
When, for example, a child wants to be carried and says, “My leg hurts
me and my foot too just here, I can’t walk, I can’t, I can’t,”[181] it
is possible at least that he soon realises the tiredness he begins by
half feigning. The Worcester collection gives an example. “I was giving
some cough syrup, and E (aged three years two months) ran to me saying:
‘I am sick too, and I want some medicine’. She then tried to cough.
Every time she would see me taking the syrup bottle afterwards, she
would begin to cough. The syrup was very sweet.” This looks simply
awful. But what if the child were of so imaginative a turn that the
sight of the syrup given to the sick child produced a more or less
complete illusion of being herself sick, an illusion strong enough to
cause the irritation and the cough? The idea may seem far-fetched, but
deserves to be considered before we brand the child with the name liar.
-----
Footnote 181:
See P. Lombroso, _op. cit._, p. 74.
-----
The vivid fanciful realisation which in this instance was sustained by
the love of sweet things is in many cases inspired by other and later
developed feelings. How much false statement—and that not only among
little children—is of the nature of exaggeration and directed to
producing a strong effect. When, for example, the little four-year-old
draws himself up and shouts exultantly, “See, mamma, how tall I am, I am
growing so fast, I shall soon be a giant,” or boasts of his strength and
tells you the impossible things he is going to do, the element of
braggadocio is on the surface, and imposes on nobody.
No doubt these propensities, though not amounting in the stage of
development now dealt with to full lying, may if unrestrained develop
into this. An unbridled fancy and strong love of effect will lead an
older child to say what he knows, vaguely at least, at the moment to be
false in order to startle and mystify others. Such exaggeration of the
impulses is distinctly abnormal, as may be seen by its affinity to what
we can observe in the case of the insane. The same is true of the
exaggeration of the vain-glorious or ‘showing off’ impulses, as
illustrated for example in the cases mentioned by Dr. Stanley Hall of
children who on going to a new town or school would assume new
characters which were kept up with difficulty by means of many false
pretences.[182]
-----
Footnote 182:
Article “Children’s Lies,” p. 67.
-----
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account