These results do not seem to agree with those of M. Passy or of
Professor Barnes. M. Passy distinguishes in children’s drawings a
front and a side view, both of which may be used by the same child at
the same time. The former consists of nose and mouth of profile and
eyes and ears of full face, the latter, of nose and mouth of profile
with one eye and one ear; that is to say the two differ only in the
number of eyes and ears (_Revue Philosophique_, 1891, p. 614 ff.). It
would be interesting to know on how large an examination this
generalisation is based. As suggested above, the occasional omission
of the second eye and ear where both are commonly used can be
explained without supposing the child to distinguish between profile
and full face. Professor Barnes goes so far as to state with numerical
exactness the relative frequency of profile and full face by children
at different stages. He makes, however, no serious attempt to explain
the criterion by which he would distinguish the two modes of
representation (see his article, _Pedagogical Seminary_, ii., p. 455
ff.).
-----
In this naïve childish art of profile drawing we have something which at
first seems far removed from the art of uncivilised races. No doubt, as
Grosse urges, the drawings of savages discovered in North America,
Africa, Australia, are technically greatly superior to children’s clumsy
impossible performances. Yet points of contact disclose themselves. If a
North American Indian is incapable of producing the stupid scheme of a
front view of the mouth and side view of the nose, he may, as we have
seen, occasionally succumb to the temptation to bring both eyes into a
profile drawing. We may see, too, how in trying to represent action, and
to exhibit the active limb as he must do laterally, the untutored
nature-man is apt to get odd results, as may be observed in the
accompanying drawing by a North American Indian of a man shooting (Fig.
39 (_a_)).[269] This may be compared with the accompanying Egyptian
drawing (Fig. 39 (_b_)).[270]
-----
Footnote 269:
Taken from Schoolcraft, vol. i., pl. 48.
Footnote 270:
From Maspero’s _Dawn of Civilisation_, p. 469.
-----
[Illustration: Fig. 39 (_a_).]
[Illustration: Fig. 39 (_b_).]
[Illustration: Fig. 40 (_a_).]
[Illustration: Fig. 40 (_b_).]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account