Studies of the Greek Poets (Vol 1 of 2)Symonds, John Addington
History
Studies of the Greek Poets (Vol 1 of 2)
Symonds, John Addington
Greek poetry -- History and criticism
"He told us that Pythodorus had described to him the appearance
of Parmenides and Zeno; they came to Athens, he said, at
the great Panathenæa; the former was, at the time of his
visit, about sixty-five years old, very white with age, but
well-favored. Zeno was nearly forty years of age, of a noble
figure and fair aspect; and in the days of his youth he was
reported to have been beloved of Parmenides. He said that they
lodged with Pythodorus in the Ceramicus, outside the wall,
whither Socrates and others came to see them; they wanted to
hear some writings of Zeno, which had been brought to Athens
by them for the first time. He said that Socrates was then
very young, and that Zeno read them to him in the absence of
Parmenides, and had nearly finished when Pythodorus entered,
and with him Parmenides and Aristoteles, who was afterwards one
of the Thirty; there was not much more to hear, and Pythodorus
had heard Zeno repeat them before."
The _Theætetus_ contains another allusion to Parmenides, which proves
in what reverence the old philosopher was held by Socrates:
"My reason is that I have a kind of reverence, not so much for
Melissus and the others, who say that 'all is one and at rest,'
as for the great leader himself, Parmenides, venerable and
awful, as in Homeric language he may be called--him I should be
ashamed to approach in a spirit unworthy of him. I met him when
he was an old man and I was a mere youth, and he appeared to me
to have a glorious depth of mind. And I am afraid that we may
not understand his language, and may fall short even more of
his meaning."
Finally, in the _Sophistes_ a passing allusion to the same event is
put into the mouth of Socrates: "I remember hearing Parmenides use
the latter of the two methods, when I was a young man and he was far
advanced in years, in a very noble discussion." These notices of
the Eleatic sage, we feel, are not in any sense accidental. Plato
has introduced them in important moments of his three most studied
dialogues upon those very points which occupied the mind of Parmenides,
and by the elaboration of which he made his greatest contribution
to philosophy. The problems of knowledge and of the relation of
the phenomenal universe to real existence were for the first time
methodically treated in the school of Elea. Their solution in the
theory of Ideas was the main object of Plato's philosophical activity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account