Studies on Homer and the Homeric Age, Vol. 1 of 3: I. Prolegomena II. Achæis; or, the Ethnology of the Greek RacesGladstone, W. E. (William Ewart)
History
Studies on Homer and the Homeric Age, Vol. 1 of 3: I. Prolegomena II. Achæis; or, the Ethnology of the Greek Races
Gladstone, W. E. (William Ewart)
Civilization, Homeric; Epic poetry, Greek -- History and criticism; Homer
The signification of the word Ἄργος will be considered hereafter: for
the present purpose it is enough to observe that the word μέσον, as
used by Menelaus, in combination with Hellas, of itself prevents our
applying it simply to the narrow corner of the Peloponnesus in which
the city of Argos was placed; and therefore that it can scarcely mean
less than Peloponnesus. And it is not less plain, that whatever may
be the force of the words when taken singly, their effect when taken
together can hardly be less than this: Menelaus must mean to point to
Greece at large, as the scene of the proposed excursion. For there is
no assignable portion of Greece to which, consistently with the words
and the sense, he can be held to confine his meaning. If we could
suppose him to mean Peloponnesus only by the two names Hellas and
Argos, which he employs in this place, we should but enlarge thereby
the Homeric capacity of the word Hellas; for we have already brought it
down from the north to Bœotia; and we should, in the way now proposed,
carry it through the isthmus, and over Peloponnesus, or, at the least,
over some part of it. But even if Menelaus means Peloponnesus only,
which is most improbable, it is plainly incredible that such should be
the meaning of Penelope in Od. i. 344. As a Greek, she _cannot_ mean to
limit the renown of her husband to any sphere less wide than Greece.
We have already seen, that Hellas sometimes includes certainly the
territory from Southern Thessaly to Bœotia, and probably Thessaly at
large: and it is quite plain that, if it comes to Bœotia, it does not
stop there, but applies to the whole of Middle Greece, the region
between Thessaly and the isthmus: for the application of the term
Hellas could not stop except at some great natural division of the
country, and the isthmus is here the only one possible.
Now the name Argos is related to Thessaly[500], but much more specially
related to the Peloponnesus, as we shall see from a number of passages.
It has no relation at all in Homer to that division of the country in
particular which we call Middle Greece.
Assuming it, then, to mean Peloponnesus, in that case Hellas means
Middle with Northern Greece: and the two names of Hellas and Argos,
taken together, completely and conveniently express the whole country.
The only alterations are such as would assign to Hellas a larger sense;
in no case can it, as to this passage, admit of a more restricted one.
The foregoing argument is supported to a certain extent by the fact,
that while territorial names are frequent for the Peloponnesian part of
Greece, (we have Achaic Argos, Iasian Argos, Elis, Arcadia, Lacedæmon,)
the continent to the north of the isthmus is generally without
territorial names: Phthia and Pelasgic Argos are, I think, the only
exceptions. There is thus before us a gap, which the name Hellas, as it
has been here construed, seems conveniently to fill.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account