Studies on Homer and the Homeric Age, Vol. 1 of 3: I. Prolegomena II. Achæis; or, the Ethnology of the Greek RacesGladstone, W. E. (William Ewart)
History
Studies on Homer and the Homeric Age, Vol. 1 of 3: I. Prolegomena II. Achæis; or, the Ethnology of the Greek Races
Gladstone, W. E. (William Ewart)
Civilization, Homeric; Epic poetry, Greek -- History and criticism; Homer
We find in Il. i. 270, iii. 49, and in Od. vii. 25, xvi. 18, the
expression ἀπίη γαίη, which some of the grammarians, and the common
opinion mentioned by Strabo[659], have explained to mean the
Peloponnesus, while modern scholars render it simply distant[660]. In
the two passages of the Iliad, the former construction is certainly
more suitable: and the combination with τηλόθεν in Il. i. 270, is
tautological, flat, and un-Homeric, if ἀπίη mean merely distant. In
Od. xvi. 18 either sense will serve the passage. In Od. vii. 25 (when
we again have τηλόθεν) Ulysses states himself to have come ἐξ ἀπίης
γαίης. As he had not come from Peloponnesus, it is assumed that this
is not the meaning. I question the reasoning. Ulysses everywhere,
when questioned, shows an immense fertility in fiction about himself:
in every case, however, carefully reporting himself to be come from
a distant spot. I see no reason therefore why we should not construe
Ἀπίη γαῖα to mean the Peloponnesus; in conformity with the tradition
which Æschylus[661] reports concerning Apis, and with the undoubted
usage of the tragedians. As I interpret the Outer or Romance-geography
of the Odyssey, the Peloponnesus would be understood by the Phæacians
of Homer to be extremely remote from their country. The difference of
quantity is no sufficient reason against this construction. Plainly
Ἀπίη γαίη, if it be a proper name at all, means the whole Peloponnesus,
and not a part of it, for Nestor in Il. i. 270 uses it so as to include
the Western side, and Hector, Il. iii. 49, so as to include the Eastern.
_Geographical definitions._
I will now sum up the conclusions to which this inquiry has brought
us, either by certain or by probable evidence, with respect to Homer’s
geographical nomenclature for Greece at large, and for its principal
members.
1. Ἀχαïὶς }
Ἀχαïὶς γαῖα } invariably mean the whole of Greece.
Ἀχαιῒς αἶα }
2. Ἄργος either alone, or with epithets other than those which concern
geographical extension, means
(1) The city only, as in Il. iv. 52, and probably in Il. ii. 559.
(2) The immediate dominions of Agamemnon in the north and north-east
of Peloponnesus, as in Od. iii. 263.
But it is possible, though by no means certain, that Ἄργος in this
sense should be held to include the whole Pelopid dominions, which
were looked upon as having a certain political unity, and thus to be
the equivalent of Ἄργος Ἀχαιïκόν.
(3) By metonymy from this supreme and metropolitan quarter of Greece,
it means the whole country.
3. The phrase πᾶν Ἄργος in Il. ii. 108 means the whole of Continental
Greece.
4. The phrase μέσον Ἄργος means most probably the whole of Greece, or
Greece at large; possibly the Peloponnesus only.
5. Πελασγικὸν Ἄργος is Thessaly, from Macedonia to Œta.
6. Ἀχαιïκὸν Ἄργος means the Pelopid dominions of the Troic time, or in
general words, Eastern Peloponnesus.
7. Ἴασον Ἄργος means Western Peloponnesus.
8. The word Ἕλλας means
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account