Sweated industry and the minimum wageBlack, Clementina
History
Sweated industry and the minimum wage
Black, Clementina
Minimum wage; Sweatshops
The scene of a sitting of the Court of Arbitration can easily be called
up from newspaper descriptions. The room is plain and not large. At the
upper end, between the two arbitrators, sits the judge in wig and gown.
Men and masters, easily distinguishable by differences of dress, manner
and speech, face each other across a table; in the body of the room
reporters and a sprinkling of spectators are gathered to listen. The
matter in hand is stated; then the representative of the men’s union or
of the associated masters sets forth the plea of his clients, no counsel
being employed except by agreement of both parties. The cost and the
duration of proceedings are, no doubt, both lessened by this provision;
and it is said that the unprofessional advocates on the two parts often
show remarkable ability in the conduct of the case.
In Victoria a different method of fixing a minimum wage has been
adopted; the method not of the Conciliation Board and Court of
Arbitration but of the Wage Board. The mechanism of the Wage Boards is
much more easily described and understood than that of the New Zealand
Boards and Court; and it is, no doubt, partly, though not wholly, upon
this account that advocates of the minimum wage are apt to propose the
Victorian rather than the New Zealand model for imitation. Personally,
however, considerable study of both plans has convinced me that the New
Zealand method is, in practice, the less cumbrous, and that it includes
features of great value that are lacking in the Victorian system.
Especially valuable seems to be the singular ease with which its
machinery can be brought to bear upon the poorest workers. Were the law
of New Zealand also the law of England I would myself engage to collect,
within six months, from each of half a dozen underpaid women’s trades
the seven workers necessary to form the required unions, and so to bring
these half dozen trades within the purview of a Conciliation Board. Such
Boards are established upon being asked for by a registered association
of workers (or of employers), whereas the Victorian Wage Boards can only
be established in any trade by a resolution of both Houses of
Parliament; and, on this side of the ocean at least, Parliaments are apt
to require much moving before they can be made to act.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account