Sweated industry and the minimum wageBlack, Clementina
History
Sweated industry and the minimum wage
Black, Clementina
Minimum wage; Sweatshops
We may seek the development of our trade along either of two lines—we
may aim either at underselling our competitors or at surpassing them. If
we elect to take the line of cheapness, and also determine to seek that
cheapness by paying very low wages, we must confine ourselves to goods
that demand neither very high skill nor very elaborate machinery. But
these are precisely the sort of goods that can best be produced by
nations upon a lower level than ourselves, by peasants and by dwellers
in genial climates where comparatively little food and clothing and
practically no heating are required. With workers such as these we can
never compete on equal terms, and we should be wiser not to try. We can
never bring down an Englishman to the standards of the Chinaman or of
the Hindoo. But we can, in making the attempt, create among ourselves a
class of helots, degraded labour slaves, living on a level that shocks
our national conscience. To do this is to keep open a sore in our midst
and to run a constant risk of those revolts and disturbances which are
the greatest possible danger and interruption to the regular course of
trade—a greater danger perhaps than that of being undersold by
foreigners. For the long-suffering of the English poor, though amazing,
is not probably quite unlimited. No national life can be stable while
large numbers of the people live in great misery. The best safeguard of
national peace is a general distribution of comfort and independence.
And the safest paths towards this state of security are good education
and good payment for the workers. Low wages lead by a path of
intolerable suffering to an inevitable downfall. On the ascending path
too there may be dangers—but they are the less dangers, and they will be
faced by citizens fitter to meet them.
After all, even Great Britain cannot expect to hold all the trade of the
world. What she may expect, what she can have if she will, is the
commercial leadership of the world. She may show in other departments,
as she has shown in cotton and in iron, that her race can produce the
best workers living, and the best organisers of work; and she can
continue the great lesson which others have learned from her history,
but which she herself does not always remember, the lesson that, other
things being equal, that nation becomes wealthiest which pays its
workers best. Health, skill, intelligence: these are the true bulwarks
of national prosperity; and the price of these is liberal payment for
labour. Nor does the prosperity which rests upon these things injure
those neighbouring nations amid which it develops. Rivalry upon the
up-grade educates and improves all alike; rivalry upon the down-grade
injures and degrades all, but not all alike. In that competition the
nation suffers most whose standards are highest.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account