"No philosophers are conceited;
Some conceited persons are not-gamblers.
.'. Some not-gamblers are not philosophers"
This can be proved by reduction to _Ferio_, thus:--
"No conceited persons are philosophers;
Some not-gamblers are conceited.
.'. Some not-gamblers are not philosophers".
The validity of _Ferio_ follows directly from the Axiom '_De Omni et
Nullo_'.
(2) _Symbolic Representation._
Before proceeding to discuss other Methods of Solution, it is necessary
to translate our Syllogism into an _abstract_ form.
Let us take "persons" as our 'Universe of Discourse'; and let
x = "philosophers", m = "conceited", and y = "gamblers."
Then the Syllogism may be written thus:--
"No x are m;
Some m are y'.
.'. Some y' are x'."
(3) _Solution by Euler's Method of Diagrams._
The Major Premiss requires only _one_ Diagram, viz.
1
_____ _____
_/ \_ _/ \_
/ \ / \
| x | | m |
\_ _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/
pg181
The Minor requires _three_, viz.
2
_____ _____
_/ \_ _/ \_
/ \ / \
| y | | m |
\_ _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/
3
_____ _____
_/ \_/ \_
/ / \ \
| y | | m |
\_ \_/ _/
\_____/ \_____/
4
_____
_/ ___ \_
/ / y \ \
| \___/ |
\_ m _/
\_____/
The combination of Major and Minor, in every possible way requires
_nine_, viz.
Figs. 1 and 2 give
5
_____ _____ _____
_/ \_ _/ \_ _/ \_
/ \ / \ / \
| x | | y | | m |
\_ _/ \_ _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/ \_____/
6
_____ _____ _____
_/ \_/ \_ _/ \_
/ / \ \ / \
| x | | y | | m |
\_ \_/ _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/ \_____/
7
_____ _____
_/ \_ _/ \_
/ \ / \
| xy | | m |
\_ _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/
8
_____ _____
_/ ___ \_ _/ \_
/ / x \ \ / \
| \___/ | | m |
\_ y _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/
9
_____ _____
_/ ___ \_ _/ \_
/ / y \ \ / \
| \___/ | | m |
\_ x _/ \_ _/
\_____/ \_____/
Figs. 1 and 3 give
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account