There can be no question that this ingenious and attractive theory, if
it were true in its special application to song, would immensely
simplify interpretation, and moreover that preferential mating would
contribute not a little to the success of the whole territorial system.
No one can deny the strength of the argument: that the sexual instinct,
like all other instincts, must require a stimulus of an appropriate
kind; that the effect of the sexual call upon the female cannot be
neutral; and hence the probability that stimulation varies too; no one,
I say, can question the strength of this evidence, and, one might add,
of the evidence derived from the analogy of the human voice. But when we
have said this, we have said all; and our acceptance of the hypothesis,
so far as song is concerned, must remain provisional so long as the
evidence remains but secondary evidence.
CHAPTER V
THE RELATION OF THE TERRITORY TO THE SYSTEM OF REPRODUCTION
In the first two chapters I tried to show that the inherited nature of
the male leads it to remain in a definite place at a definite season and
to become intolerant of the approach of members of its own sex, and that
a result is thus attained which the word "territory" in some measure
describes. But the use of this word is nevertheless open to criticism,
for it denotes a human end upon which the highest faculties have been
brought to bear, and consequently we have to be on our guard lest our
conception of the "territory" should tend to soar upwards into regions
which require a level of mental development not attained by the bird. It
is necessary to bear this in mind now we have come to consider the
meaning of the territory, or rather the position that it occupies in the
whole scheme of reproduction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account