place: when we move it to another region, there is no knowing how it
will alter. We do assume, however, that, if it alters, it alters bit
by bit, gradually, continuously, and not by sudden jumps. Perhaps
this assumption is unjustified. It belongs to the general outlook of
relativity, which is that of continuity. No doubt it is owing to this
outlook that relativity is unable to account for the discontinuities in
physics, such as quanta, electrons and protons. Perhaps relativity will
conquer these domains when it learns to dispense with the assumption of
continuity.
Finally we come to geography, in which I include history. The
separation of history from geography rests upon the separation of time
from space; when we amalgamate the two in space-time, we need one word
to describe the combination of geography and history. For the sake of
simplicity, I shall use the one word geography in this extended sense.
Geography, in this sense, includes everything that, as a matter of
crude fact, distinguishes one part of space-time from another. One
part is occupied by the sun, one by the earth; the intermediate
regions contain light waves, but no matter (apart from a very little
here and there). There is a certain degree of theoretical connection
between different geographical facts; to establish this is the purpose
of physical laws. It is thought that a sufficient knowledge of the
geographical facts of the solar system throughout any finite time,
however short, would enable an ideally competent physicist to predict
the future of the solar system so long as it remained remote from other
stars. We are already in a position to calculate the large facts about
the solar system backwards and forwards for vast periods of time. But
in all such calculations we need a basis of crude fact. The facts are
interconnected, but facts can only be inferred from other facts, not
from general laws alone. Thus the facts of geography have a certain
independent status in physics. No amount of physical laws will enable
us to infer a physical fact unless we know other facts as data for our
inference. And here when I speak of “facts” I am thinking of particular
facts of geography, in the extended sense in which I am using the term.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account