tribunal of fact, to the demonstration of which we will now proceed. To
this matter I attribute very great importance. It is on this ground,
according to my opinion, that the whole battle must be fought out
between the generally accepted view that every agency is capable of
exciting the gastric mucous membrane and the theory that it is only
excitable by specific and selected stimuli. If once the defenders of
the old opinion are driven from their position and obliged to admit
the inefficiency of mechanical stimulation, there would be nothing
further left for them than to build up new theories and search out
old facts concerning gland work which have hitherto been rigidly kept
in the shade. We may take it that it is mainly because people were so
seized with the belief in the direct and simple mechanical explanation
that Bidder and Schmidt’s experiment of the excitation of gastric
secretion by mental effect has been so little taken into consideration,
notwithstanding that it appeared so thoroughly reliable and convincing.
I will now repeat the experiment of mechanical stimulation of the
gastric mucous membrane before you in the well-known, traditional,
and classic manner. Here is a dog with a gastric fistula on which
a cervical œsophagotomy has in addition been performed. I open the
fistula; as you see, nothing flows out of the stomach; it was washed
out clean with water an hour ago. We take the celebrated feather and
also a tolerably strong glass rod. Folds of blotting-paper saturated
with red and blue tincture of litmus are placed at hand. I now ask my
assistant to continuously move the feather and glass rod, alternately,
in all possible directions in the stomach, changing from one to the
other every five minutes. On removal from the stomach each is carefully
dried with red and blue blotting-paper. You have all seen, gentlemen,
that this procedure has now been kept up for half an hour. From the
fistular orifice not even a single drop has escaped, and, moreover, the
drops of moisture on all the pieces of red blotting-paper I have been
able to hand to you have assumed a distinct blue tinge, caused by the
moisture of the alkaline mucous membrane. The blue pieces, however,
have merely been made wet without altering their colour. Consequently,
with the most thorough mechanical stimulation of the whole cavity of
the stomach, we have not been able to find a single spot possessing a
noticeable acid reaction. Where, then, are the streams of pure gastric
juice of which we read in text-books! What objection can be raised
against the conclusiveness of this experiment? In my opinion only one:
that we are dealing with a dog out of health, whose gastric glands from
some possible cause are unable to react normally. This single objection
can be set aside before your eyes. After failing with the mechanical
stimulation, we proceed forthwith to the sham feeding of the same
animal. The dog takes the food offered it with keen appetite, and you
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account