These motor habits are essential in generating common-sense beliefs,
which arise at a much later stage of mental growth. Common sense,
in its more primitive form, is hardly aware that there is such an
occurrence as perceiving; it is only aware of the perceived object.
And by the time that even the most rudimentary reflection begins,
each sense calls out responses connected with other senses, so that
even when, from the standpoint of external stimulus, only one sense
is affected, the experience has the massiveness of something in which
several senses are involved. See, for example, the pictures in Kohler's
Mentality of Apes: here we see chimpanzees which are watching
others with sympathetic movements of the arms that indicate stimulation
of bodily feelings connected with balance, although the sole stimulus
is visual. This accounts for the fact that common sense can so
confidently identify an object touched and not seen with an[Pg 149] object
seen but not touched—e.g. the cricket-ball now successfully
caught and the same ball as it flew through the air. The reason is
that the experience is always richer than the sensory stimulus alone
would warrant: it contains always responses arising from physiological
experience of past correlations. If an adult were to hear a donkey's
bray for the first time, without having previously known that there
was an animal which made that noise, his experience would be amazingly
unlike that of a normal adult in the same circumstances.
Common sense does not initially distinguish as sharply as civilized
nations do between persons, animals, and things. Primitive religion
affords abundant evidence of this. A thing, like an animal, has a sort
of power residing within it: it may fall on your head, roll over in the
wind, and so on. It is only gradually that inanimate objects become
sharply separated from people, through the observation that their
actions have no purpose. But animals are not separable from people
on this ground, and are in fact thought by savages to be much more
intelligent than they are.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account