Physics traditionally ignores quality, and reduces the physical
world to matter in motion. This view is no longer adequate. Energy
turns out to be more important than matter, and light possesses many
properties—e.g. gravitation—which were formerly regarded as
characteristic of matter. The substitution of space-time for space
and time has made it natural to regard events, rather than persistent
substances, as the raw material of physics. Quantum phenomena have
thrown doubt on continuity of motion. For these and other reasons, the
old simplicities have disappeared.
When we start from perception instead of from mathematical physics,
we find that the events with which we are best acquainted have
"qualities," by means of which they can be arranged in classes
and series. All colours have something in common which is not
possessed by sounds. Two colours may be so similar as to be almost
or quite indistinguishable, but they may also be very dissimilar. As
Gestalt-psychologie has emphasized, shapes are perceived qualitatively,
not analytically as a system of interrelated parts. But this whole
conception of quality, which plays such a large part in our perceptual
life, has been wholly absent from traditional physics. Colours, sounds,
temperatures, etc., have all been[Pg 346] regarded as caused by various kinds
of motions. There was no objection to this so far as it succeeded, but,
if and where it proves insufficient, there can also be no objection to
re-introducing qualitative differences into the physical world.
There is, however, one essential limitation. We may find reasons for
supposing qualitative differences, in order to be able to build up
the kind of structure which we have inferred; but we cannot have any
means of knowing what are the qualities which differ. This point was
discussed in Part II., and need not now detain us.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account