This view of causal laws is absent from quantum theory, from the ideas
of savages and uneducated persons, and from the works of philosophers,
including Bergson and J. S. Mill. In quantum theory, we have a discrete
series of possible[Pg 102] sudden changes, and a certain statistical knowledge
of the proportion of cases in which each possibility is realized;
but we have no knowledge as to what determines the occurrence of a
particular change in a particular case. Moreover, the change is not
of the sort that can be expressed by differential equations: it is a
change from a state expressed by one integer or set of integers to a
state expressed by another. This kind of change may turn out to be
physically ultimate, and to mark out at least a part of physics as
governed by laws of a new sort. But we are not likely to find science
returning to the crude form of causality believed in by Fijians and
philosophers, of which the type is "lightning causes thunder." It can
never be a law that, given at one time, there is sure to be
at another time, because something might intervene to prevent n .
We do not derive such laws from quantum phenomena, because we do not,
in their case, know that will not continue throughout the time in
question. The natural view to take at present is that quantum phenomena
have to do with the interchange of energy between matter and the
surrounding medium, while continuous change is found in all processes
which involve no such interchange. There are, however, difficulties
in any view at present, and it is not for a layman to venture an
opinion. It seems not improbable that, as Heisenberg suggests, our
views of space-time may have to be modified profoundly before harmony
is achieved between quantum phenomena and the laws of transmission
of light in vacuo. For the moment, however, I wish to confine
myself to the standpoint of relativity theory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account