In tracing the limits of the Culm-measures, De la Beche found that no well-defined line could be drawn between these strata and the "grauwacke" or Devonian formations underneath. The Carboniferous series lies in a great trough, of which the axis runs nearly east and west, so that the lowest members of the series rise along the northern and southern margins. But De la Beche was struck with one remarkable contrast between the two opposite sides of the trough--a contrast which marks the Devonian as well as the Carboniferous formations of this region. On the south side an abundant and persistent group of intercalated bands of igneous, or as he called them, "trappean," materials can be followed along the whole line of boundary, while no such group occurs on the north side. He found these bands to be lenticular, traceable sometimes for a number of miles, then dying out and reappearing on the same or other horizons. He mapped them the whole way from Boscastle on the west to near Exeter on the east, and found that though the individual sheets might be short, the trappean zone was continuous as far as the southern margin of the Carboniferous series could be seen, except where it had been broken through by the great granitic mass of Dartmoor. He ascertained that the intercalated trappean rocks are not confined to the Culm-measures, but occur also in the contiguous portions of the "grauwacke" or Devonian system. But further, he clearly recognized that the bands of igneous material which he mapped included both "greenstones," together with other varieties of massive eruptive rocks, and also volcanic ash or tuff, though he did not attempt to separate these out upon the maps, but contented himself with representing them all under the same colour. He admitted that some doubt might be entertained as to the age of the greenstones, for some of them might be intrusive and therefore later than the sedimentary deposits between which they lie. But he contended that there could be no uncertainty with regard to the trappean ash or tuff, which being regularly interstratified in the Carboniferous series, must be contemporaneous with it. He pointed out that many of the greenstones, as well as fragments in the conglomerates or ashes, were highly vesicular and must originally have been in the condition of pumice.