The art of music. Vol. 01 (of 14) : $b The pre-Classic periods
History
The art of music. Vol. 01 (of 14) : $b The pre-Classic periods
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
It has already been related how, even as early as 1322, the liberties
which careless, ignorant, or sacrilegious singers took with the Roman
service had called forth denunciations from the papal chair. The
genius of the Netherland schools, dominating church music as it did
for a space of two hundred years, was, like Janus, two-faced. On the
one hand, it developed a musical technique so complete and perfect in
form that any further progress without an entire change of principle
seemed impossible; and, on the other, it fostered a dry, mathematical
correctness that led, at its worst, to an utter disregard of expression
and feeling. Only the genius of a Josquin or a Lasso rendered learning
subservient to beauty of expression and carried out the true mission of
art.
In Rome, however, no master had yet appeared who was great enough to
force into the background all the unsanctioned innovations by which
unscrupulous musicians sought to reach the popular taste. From the
time of the return of the popes from Avignon (1377) Roman church
music had been a continual source of dissatisfaction to the Curia. As
has been pointed out, the plain-chant became more and more overladen
with contrapuntal embellishments; the mass sometimes exhibited a
labored canon worked over a long, slow _cantus firmus_, the different
voices singing different sets of words entirely unconnected with each
other. Sometimes, again, the ritual was enlivened by texts beginning
with the words _Baisez moy; Adieu, mes amours_; or the much tortured
_Omme armé_, of which the tunes were as worldly as the text. If
these objections were lacking, another was likely to be present in
the absurdly elaborate style, which rendered the words of so little
importance that they might as well not have existed at all. The mass,
'bristling with inept and distracting artifices,’ had lost all relation
to the service it was supposed to illustrate. 'It was usual for the
most solemn phrases of the Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, or Agnus Dei to blend
along the aisles of the basilica with the unedifying refrains of the
lewd chansons of Flanders and Provence.’[123] In this manner the
beautiful ritual was either degraded by pedants into a mere learned
conundrum, or by idlers into a sacrilegious and profane exercise; and
the reproofs of popes and councils had, so far, not availed to keep out
these signs of deterioration, much less to lift church music to the
level of the sister arts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account