The art of music, Vol. 02 (of 14) : $b Classicism and Romanticism
History
The art of music, Vol. 02 (of 14) : $b Classicism and Romanticism
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
Franz is one of those composers of whose work little can be told in
print. It is all in the music. Unlike Schubert and Schumann, he limited
himself in his choice of subjects, taking mostly poems of delicate
sentiments, and avoiding all that was realistic. Unlike Schubert, he
worked over his songs with greatest care, sometimes keeping them for
years before he had fashioned them to perfection. His voice parts are,
on the whole, more independent than Schumann’s. They combine perfect
declamatory freedom and accurate observance of the text with a delicate
finish of melodic grace. The accompaniments are in many styles. Broken
chords he uses with distinction, so that the individual notes seem
not only harmonic but melodic in their function. In him, more than in
previous song writers, polyphony (deriving from his familiarity with
Bach) plays a prominent part. He is a master in the use of delicate
dissonance, and in some ways the poetry of his accompaniments looks
forward to the ‘atmospheric’ effects of what we loosely term the
‘impressionistic school.’ He does not strike the heights or depths of
emotion, but his music at times is as moving as any in song literature.
Above all, he stands for the perfect and intimate union of text and
music, in a more subtle way than was accomplished either by Schubert or
Schumann.
Mendelssohn wrote many songs during his days of fame, which had a
popularity far outshining that of the songs we have been speaking
of. They sold in great abundance, especially in England, and fetched
extraordinary prices from publishers. But by this time they have sunk
pretty nearly into oblivion. They are polished, as all his work is,
and have the quality of instantly pleasing a hearer who doesn’t care
to listen too hard. Needless to say, their musicianship is above
reproach. But their melody, while graceful, is undistinguished, and
their emotional message is superficial.
Chopin, however, composed a little book of Polish songs which deserves
to be immortal. They purported to be arrangements of Polish melodies
together with original songs in the same spirit. As a matter of fact,
they are probably almost altogether Chopin’s work. In them we find the
highest refinement of melodic contour, and an exotic poetry in the
accompaniments such as none but Chopin, at the time, could write. ‘The
Maiden’s Wish’ is perhaps the only one familiar to the general public,
and that chiefly through Liszt’s piano arrangement of it. But among the
others there are some of the first rank, particularly the ‘Baccanale,’
‘My Delights,’ and ‘Poland’s Dirge.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account