The art of music, Vol. 02 (of 14) : $b Classicism and Romanticism
History
The art of music, Vol. 02 (of 14) : $b Classicism and Romanticism
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
Schumann’s first twenty-six published works (covering \ most of the
decade from 1830 to 1840) were almost exclusively for the piano. From
the beginning he showed his instinct for its technical possibilities.
Opus 1, published in November, 1831, was a set of variations, the theme
being the musical ‘spelling’ of the name of a woman friend of his, the
‘Countess Abegg,’ perhaps as much a product of the imagination as was
the music itself. The variations show the crudities of dilettantism, as
well as its enthusiasm and courage. They were far from being the formal
mechanical variations of classical clavier music. No change of the
theme but has a musical and expressive beauty apart from its technical
ingenuity. Especially they reveal a vivid sense of what the piano could
do as distinguished from what the clavichord or harpsichord could do.
Much better was opus 2, the _Papillons_, or ‘Butterflies,’ which is
still popular on concert programs. All that is typical of Schumann the
pianist is to be found in some measure in this opus 2. For, besides the
vivid joy they reveal in experimentation with pianistic effects, there
is the fact that they came, by way of Schumann’s colorful imagination,
out of literature. Here was romanticism going full tilt. From his
earliest years Schumann had adored his Jean Paul. He had equally adored
his piano. When he read the one he heard the other echoing. This was
precisely the origin of the _Papillons_, as Schumann confessed in
letters to his friends. The various dances of opus 2 are the portions
of the masked dance of the conclusion of Jean Paul’s _Flegeljahre_--not
as program music, nor even as pictorial music, but in the vaguest
way the creation of the sensitive musician under the stimulus of
literature. Schumann attached no especial value to the fanciful titles
which he gave much of his piano music; in his later revisions of it he
usually withdrew them altogether. He always insisted that the music and
not the literature was the important thing in his music. The names
which betitle his music were often afterthoughts. They were nearly
always given in a playful spirit. The literary music of Schumann is not
in the least music which expresses literature, but only music written
by a sensitive musician under the creative stimulus of literature.
The ‘Butterflies’ of opus 2 (_Papillons_) are by no means the
flittering, showy butterflies common to salons of that day. They are
free and fanciful dances, rich in harmonic and technical device, and
rich especially in buoyant high spirits. The canons, the free melodic
counterpoint, the recurrence of passages to give unity to the series,
the broken or rolling chords, the spicy rhythmical devices, the
blending of voices in a manner quite different from the polyphonic
style of old, and the use of single anticipatory or suspended notes for
changes of key--these gave evidence of what was to be the nature of
Schumann’s contribution to piano literature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account