The art of music, Vol. 05 (of 14) : $b The voice and vocal music
History
The art of music, Vol. 05 (of 14) : $b The voice and vocal music
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
We have not yet finished with the process of ‘placing’ Wolf (1860-1903)
as a song writer, but there are competent critics who would rank him
above Schubert (that is, as the greatest in musical history) and any
number who would rank him just below. Certainly his work is free
from any of the careless or conventional writing which disfigures so
much of Schubert’s work. The standard which Wolf set for himself in
his song-writing is perhaps more exacting than that set by any other
composer. His songs measure up to more separate tests than do those of
any other one man. It is evident, then, that his musicianship must have
been of the highest order. He had the benefit of the great generation
of musicians who had followed Schubert and brought to maturity the
work which he had only begun. Schubert was too often content with a
type accompaniment, a conventional turn of phrase which only serves
to fill up a measure and (what is worse) with an indifferent bit of
music when something first-rate didn’t enter his head. Moreover, his
technique, from the point of view of accurate emotional expression, was
necessarily limited, since his task was a comparatively new one. Wolf
had this one immense external advantage--that he began his work after
‘Tristan’ had been written. He was able to write his songs with an
accurate acquaintance with the most powerful emotional idiom the world
has ever seen. Whether or not Wolf was the superior of Schubert in
absolute genius is another matter. But undoubtedly, taken all in all,
his songs must satisfy modern ears and modern demands better than those
of Schubert.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account