The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
History
The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
Yet, though in looking over the _Années de pèlerinage_ one may find but
a very few pieces of genuine worth, though most are pretentious, there
is in all a certain sort of fire which one cannot approach without
being warmed. It is the glorious spirit of Byron in music. There is the
facility of Byron, the posturing of Byron, the oratory of Byron; but
there is his superb self-confidence too, showing him tricking himself
as well as the public, yet at times a hero, and Byron’s unquenchable
enthusiasm and irrepressible passionateness.
Finally we come to the small group of big pieces in which we find the
sonata in B minor, the two concertos, several études, polonaises and
concert pieces. Among the études, the great twelve have been already
touched upon. Besides these the two best known are those in D-flat
major and in F minor. The former is wholly satisfactory. The latter
is at once more difficult and less spontaneous. The two polonaises,
one in C minor and one in E major, have the virtues which belong to
concert pieces in the style of Weber’s _Polacca_, the chief of which is
enormous brilliance. In addition to this that in C minor is not lacking
in a certain nobility; but that in E major is all of outward show.
The two concertos are perfect works of their kind, unexcelled in
brilliancy of treatment of both the orchestra and the piano, and that
in E-flat major full of musical beauty. Both are free in form and
rhapsodical in character, effusions of music at once passionate and
poetical. That in A major loses by somewhat too free a looseness of
form. Even after careful study it cannot but seem rambling.
The sonata in B minor is perhaps Liszt’s boldest experiment in
original music for the pianoforte alone. One says experiment quite
intentionally, because the work shows as a whole more ingenuity than
inspiration, is rather an invention than a creation. There are measures
of great beauty, pages of factitious development. At times one finds a
nobility of utterance, at others a paucity of ideas.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account