The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
History
The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
The two long pieces are far more distinctly original. The first of
these is a set of three fanciful pieces called _Poëmes des Montagnes_.
The first of these--_Le chant des bruyères_--is divided into five
parts: the song of the heather, or the heath, mists, a touch of
Weber, a theme which is to be found in all three movements called _La
bien-aimée_, and finally the song of the heath again, this time in
the distance. The second movement is again subdivided, this time into
dances amid which _la bien-aimée_ makes a momentary appearance; and
in the last movement--_Plein-air_--one finds a promenade, thoughts
of great trees (_hêtres et pins_) on the side of the mountain, _la
bien-aimée_, a bit of calm before a burst of wind, finally a pair of
lovers united. At the beginning and at the end of the series there are
a few broken chords, vaguely styled _Harmonies_, and at the very end
again there is a reminiscence of the theme of _la bien-aimée_.
One cannot but find the whole series closely akin to Schumann. The
romanticism is the romanticism of Schumann, carried a step into the
open air and among the mountains, of his devotion to which d’Indy has
left many a proof in music. The fleeting touch of Weber, and especially
that d’Indy should have written Weber’s name over the measure in which
it falls, is again characteristic of the composer who introduced
Paganini and Chopin into his _Carnaval_. The identification of a theme
with a beloved one is another instance. But even more definite than
these tokens of a certain romanticism is the treatment of the piano,
and even the nature of much of the thematic material. _Le chant des
bruyères_ and _La bien-aimée_ are in the mold of Schumann. The _Valse
grotesque_ recalls in rhythm some of the _Davidsbündler_ and the
first of these _Danses rhythmiques_ is like parts of the Pantalon and
Colombine of the _Carnaval_.
On the other hand, there is something original and new in the section
called _Brouillard_. The general mistiness of the harmonies, the
long holding of the pedals with consequent vague obscurity of sound,
and the irregular line of clear points in a sort of melody that is
drawn against this inarticulate accompanying murmur, these indicate
new ventures in pianoforte style. The rhythmical irregularity of the
first of the dances and the irregularity in the form and recurrence
of sections are further signs of the advent of something rich and
strange. In fact the whole work loses somewhat by the frequent
suggestion of bold experiment, and is hardly to be considered equal
to the traditional standard of music, as represented by Schumann,
nor sufficiently successful to establish a new one. Barring the
_Brouillard_, the treatment of the keyboard lacks distinction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account