The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
History
The art of music, Vol. 07 (of 14) : $b Pianoforte and chamber music
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
Other fugues in the same collection, such as those in C-sharp minor and
in B-flat minor, are more architectural. But, though the marvellous
building up of themes and counter-themes, as in the C-sharp minor
fugue, seems to outline a very cathedral of sound, we shall find none
the less the same tri-partite harmonic base underneath the work as a
whole.
In longer fugues, such as the great one in C minor coupled with a
toccata and that in D minor which is associated with the ‘Chromatic
Fantasy,’ the balance between the opening and closing sections is
somewhat obscured by the long free section in between. But even here a
unity is maintained by the skillful repetition of striking passages and
the return to the final section is always magnificently prepared.
Bach did not bind himself to rules in writing his fugues. He handled
his material with great freedom. Witness many fugues like that in F
minor in the second part of the ‘Well-tempered Clavichord,’ in which
he often subdued the main theme to a capricious, obvious second theme.
Such a treatment of the fugue approaches the dramatic; and this,
together with the division, quite clear in so many, into three sections
of exposition, development and restatement, cannot but suggest some
sort of kinship between the fugue as Bach conceived it and the movement
in so-called sonata form which grew to such splendid proportions in
the half-century after his death. At any rate, we are compelled to
recognize that in spite of the contrapuntal style, inherited from an
age in which harmonic sequence was a secondary element in music, the
Bach fugues owe their imperishable form to the same principles of
harmonic foundation as those upon which the sonata-form of Mozart and
Beethoven is known to rest.
VI
Though in the matter of musical form the name of Bach at once suggests
the fugue, he brought the suite to no less perfection and significance.
It must, however, be granted that the suite suffers by comparison with
the fugue as a great form in music. First, the convention that all its
movements be in the same key is more than likely to make the work as
a whole monotonous. Secondly, the more or less obligatory dependence
upon dance rhythms tends to restrict emotional vivacity and subtlety.
Thirdly, since there can be but little contrast and variety among the
separate movements, the suite lacks organic or internal life.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account