The Atlantic Monthly, Volume 16, No. 95, September 1865: A Magazine of Literature, Art, and PoliticsVarious
General
The Atlantic Monthly, Volume 16, No. 95, September 1865: A Magazine of Literature, Art, and Politics
Various
American periodicals
In another way, also, the war will prove a drawback upon forming an
effective militia system. We shall have, for some years to come, no
class disposed to take a very hearty part in it. For a returned soldier
to find pleasure in drilling is as if a wood-sawyer, at the close of his
week's work, should bring his tools into his sitting-room, and saw for
fun. On the other hand, those who have not served in the army will feel
some natural sensitiveness about playing soldier in presence of
veterans, and being satirized, perhaps, as a mere home-guard. Thus
experience and inexperience will equally tend to deplete the classes
available for this form of service.
These obstacles will be increased by the fact, that such duties, under
any conceivable arrangement, must involve a sacrifice both in time and
money. Reduce the period of annual service to its minimum, and it may
still occur at such a time as to cost an employer his contract, or an
_employé_ his place. Our young men are to meet the problem of increased
taxes, crowded occupations, and great competition. Who shall make the
needful sacrifice? The returned soldiers? But they have given precious
years of time already. The inexperienced? But they will naturally
reason, that they have already borne the immediate financial burden of
the war, and that the drilling should be done by those to whom it will
cost no additional time to learn it. Thus all will regard their days as
being too valuable to be used in preparing for a contingency which may
never arise: one half standing aloof because they have been soldiers,
and the other half because they have not.
A difficult problem seems, then, to lie before us: To find a class
available for purposes of military training,--a class which shall claim
exemption on grounds neither of experience nor of inexperience,--which
shall be discouraged neither by the ennui of knowing too much, nor by
the awkwardness of knowing too little,--and which, withal, can spare the
time, without financial detriment to the community. Fortunately, the
solution of the problem suggests itself, in part at least, almost as
soon as the problem itself is stated. Train the school-boys.
Every person who has taken any interest in athletic exercises knows the
enormous advantage in their acquisition which the mere fact of youth
confers. In gymnastics, swimming, skating, base-ball, cricket, it is the
same thing. As a mere matter of economy, one half the time at least is
saved in teaching children as compared with full-grown men. But more
than this, it is for them not only no loss in time, but, if it can be
taken out of their regular school-hours, it is a positive advantage.
There is probably but one conceivable position in which all the
physiologists agree, and that is, that the average time now given to
study in our schools is at least one hour too long. Take this hour and
devote it to military drill, and you benefit the whole rising generation
doubly,--by what you take away, and by what you give.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account