The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentationHolst, Helge
Science
The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentation
Holst, Helge
Atomic theory
For instance, in order to understand that grating spectra can be
produced at all, we must think of a co-operation of the light from all
the rulings (cf. Fig. 10, p. 47), and this co-operation cannot arise
if all the slits at a given moment do not receive light emitted from
the same atom. In a bundle of rays which comes in at right angles to a
grating, we must, in order to explain the interference, assume that the
state of oscillation at a given moment is the same in all slits, that,
for instance, there are wave crests in all at the same time, if we
borrow a picture from the representation of water waves. Only in this
case there can behind the grating at certain fixed places—for which the
difference in the wave-length of the distances from successive slits is
a whole number of wave-lengths—steadily come wave crests from all the
slits at one moment and wave troughs from all at another moment (the
classical explanation of the “mechanism” of a grating). If we imagine,
however, that some slits are hit by light quanta from one atom and
others from a second atom, it is pure chance if there are wave crests
simultaneously in all slits, because the different atoms in a source
of light emit light at different times, depending purely on chance. An
understanding of the observed effect of a grating on light seems then
out of question.
The theory of light quanta may thus be compared with medicine which
will cause the disease to vanish but kill the patient. When Einstein,
who has made so many essential contributions in the field of the
quantum theory, advocated these remarkable representations about the
propagation of radiation energy he was naturally not blind to the
great difficulties just indicated. His apprehension of the mysterious
light in which the phenomena of interference appear on his theory is
shown in the fact that in his considerations he introduces something
which he calls a “ghost” field of radiation to help to account for the
observed facts. But he has evidently wished to follow the paradoxical
in the phenomena of radiation out to the end in the hope of making some
advance in our knowledge.
This matter is introduced here because the Einstein light quanta have
played an important part in discussions about the quantum theory,
and some readers may have heard about them without being clear as to
the real standing of the theory of light quanta. The fact must be
emphasized that this theory in no way has sprung from the Bohr theory,
to say nothing of its being a necessary consequence of it.
In the Bohr theory, absorption and radiation must be said to be
completely reciprocal processes, _i.e._ processes of essentially
the same nature, but proceeding in opposite directions. In itself it
cannot be said to be more incomprehensible that an atom absorbs energy
from a field of radiation in agreement with the Bohr postulates than
that it emits energy into the field; but in both cases we naturally
encounter the great difficulties mentioned in Chap. V.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account