The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentationHolst, Helge
Science
The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentation
Holst, Helge
Atomic theory
If we try to illustrate the matter with an analogy from the theory
of sound, we can do so by comparing the atom not with a stringed
instrument, but with a hypothetical musical instrument of a wholly
different kind. Let us imagine that we have placed one over another
and concentrically a series of circular discs of progressively smaller
radii, and let us suppose that a small sphere can move around any
one of these without friction and without emitting sound. In such a
motion the system may be said to be in a “stationary state.” Sooner
or later the sphere may fall from the first disc on to one lower down
and continue to roll around on the second, having emitted a sound, let
us assume, by its fall. By passing thus from one stationary state to
another it loses a quantity of energy equal to the work which would be
necessary to raise it again to the disc previously occupied, and to
bring it back to the original state of motion. We can assume that the
energy which is lost in the fall reappears in a sound wave emitted by
the instrument, and that the pitch of the sound emitted is proportional
to the energy sent out. If, moreover, we imagine that the lowermost
disc is grooved in such a way that the sphere cannot fall farther, then
this fanciful instrument can provide a very rough analogy with the Bohr
atom. We must beware, however, of stretching the analogy farther than
is here indicated.
It must be specially emphasized here that the frequency of the sound
emitted in the above example has no connection with the frequency of
revolution of the sphere. In the Bohr atom, likewise, the frequency
of revolution ω of the electron in its stationary orbit has no direct
connection with the frequency of the radiation emitted when the
electron passes from this orbit to another. This is a very surprising
break with all previous views on radiation, a break whose revolutionary
character should not be under-estimated. But, however unreasonable it
might seem to give up the direct connection between the revolutional
frequency and the radiation frequency, it was absolutely necessary if
the Rutherford atomic model was to be preserved. And as we shall now
see, the new point of view of the Bohr theory leads naturally to an
interpretation of the Balmer-Ritz formula, which had previously not
been connected with any other physical theory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account