The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentationHolst, Helge
Science
The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentation
Holst, Helge
Atomic theory
We can now realize that the Bohr theory takes us into unknown regions,
that it points towards fundamental laws of nature about which we
previously had no ideas. The fundamental postulates of electrodynamics,
which for a long time seemed to be the fundamental laws of the physical
world itself, by which there was hope of explaining the laws of
mechanics and of light and of everything else, were disclosed by the
Bohr theory as merely superficial and only applicable to large-scale
phenomena. The apparently exact account of the activities of nature,
obtained by the formulæ of electrodynamics, often veiled processes of
a nature entirely different from those the formulæ were supposed to
describe.
One might then express some surprise that the laws of electrodynamics
could have been obtained at all and interpreted as the most fundamental
of all laws. It must, however, be remembered that the Bohr theory for
large wave-lengths, _i.e._, the slow oscillations, leads to a
formal agreement with electrodynamics. It must, moreover, be remembered
that the laws of electrodynamics are established on the basis of
large-scale electric and magnetic processes which do not refer to
the activities of separate atoms, but in which very great numbers of
electrons are carried in a certain direction in the electric conductors
or vibrate in oscillations which are extremely slow compared with light
oscillations. Moreover, the observed laws, even if they can account
for many phenomena in light, early showed their inability to explain
the nature of the spectrum and many other problems connected with
the detailed structure of matter. Indeed the more this structure was
studied, the greater became the difficulties, the stronger the evidence
that the solution cannot be obtained in the classical way.
If we ask whether Bohr has succeeded in setting up new fundamental
laws, which can be quantitatively formulated, to replace the laws of
electrodynamics and to be used in the derivation of everything that
happens in the atom and so in all nature, this question must receive
a negative answer. The motion of the electron in a given stationary
state may, at any rate to a considerable extent, be calculated by the
laws of mechanics. We do not know, however, why certain orbits are,
in this way, preferred over others, nor why the electrons jump from
outer to inner orbits, nor why they sometimes go from one stationary
orbit to the next and sometimes jump over one or more orbits, nor why
they cannot come any closer to the nucleus than the innermost orbit,
nor why, in these transitions, they emit radiation of a frequency
determined according to the rules mentioned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account