The Basis of Social Relations: A Study in Ethnic PsychologyBrinton, Daniel G. (Daniel Garrison)
Science
The Basis of Social Relations: A Study in Ethnic Psychology
Brinton, Daniel G. (Daniel Garrison)
Ethnopsychology; Sociology
Even in the mixed populations of modern states, the connection of mental
with physical heredity is manifest. Commenting on the population of
France, Dr. Collignon observes: “To the difference of races, a purely
anatomical fact attested by the form of the skull, the colour of the
eyes and hair, and similar bodily traits, there corresponds a cerebral
difference, which shows itself in the prevailing direction of the
thoughts, and in special aptitudes.” These contrasts are shown by the
statistics of Jacoby, who examined the birth and lineage of the most
eminent men of France in all departments of activity. He found that the
Normans were decidedly ahead in the exact sciences and practical
affairs, while in poetry, romance, and works of imagination in general
the people of the Midi were far superior to them.
Heredity is believed to present itself in another aspect, which has
excited much attention. I refer to that form of it called “atavism” or
“ancestral reversion,” or “retrogression,” in which a child “takes
after,” not his immediate parents, but some remote ancestor; even, as
has been often claimed, so remote as beyond the limits of our own
species. Such traits have been called “pithecoid” (ape-like) reversions,
as they are alleged to be derived from some four-footed precursor of
man, an ape, or even a lemur.
Evolutionists whose enthusiasm transcended their discretion have pointed
out many such features in the human skeleton. A few years ago (1894) I
gathered these together, and in a paper read before the American
Association for the Advancement of Science, I undertook to prove that
these features can be satisfactorily explained by mechanical and
functional processes acting in the individual life or in that of his
immediate ancestors, and that we have no occasion to appeal to
hypotheses of descent, which have, at least, never been proved. Other
American anatomists (Bowditch, Baker) endorsed and supported by further
evidence this position, so that physical anthropologists, in our country
at least, have said less about atavism than formerly; and the final blow
to it has been dealt quite lately by a Dutch writer, Dr. Kohlbrügge. He
has established the thesis that “all so-called atavistic anomalies are
meaningless for the race-type. They are brought about by arrests of
development or general variability. They depend on disturbances of
nutrition, leading to excess or deficiency of productive energy,
presenting a deceptive appearance of progressive or retrogressive
evolution.”
The consideration of these questions in physical heredity is necessary
in psychology, whether individual or ethnic, not merely because the laws
of physical run parallel to those of psychical life, but as well for the
valuation of those expressions about “men recurring to their brute
ancestors” in habits or feelings, so frequent in popular literature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account