The Biotic Associations of CockroachesRoth, Louis M. (Louis Marcus)
Science
The Biotic Associations of Cockroaches
Roth, Louis M. (Louis Marcus)
Cockroaches; Insects -- Ecology
In contrast to the presumably amicable associations mentioned above,
other observations in the literature seem to indicate that some species
of cockroaches are incompatible when they attempt to occupy the same
habitat niche. Marlatt (1915) stated "Rarely do two of the domestic
species occur together in the same house. Often, also, of two
neighboring districts one may be infested with one species, while in the
other a distinct species is the commoner one. The different species are
thus seemingly somewhat antagonistic, and it is even supposed that they
may prey upon one another, the less numerous species being often driven
out." Phelps (1924) stated "Roaches of different species are rarely
found together, although roaches of the same species live together on
very amicable terms."
In 1859 Darwin (1887) stated that "In Russia the small Asiatic cockroach
[_Blattella germanica?_] has everywhere driven before it its great
congener [_Blatta orientalis?_]." Yet in France Girard (1877) suggested
that the oriental cockroach be introduced into a restaurant infested
with the German cockroach as the best way to expel the latter, because
the more robust species drives away cockroaches of smaller size. Wille
(1920) in Germany found usually only one species of cockroach in a
house. Yet when he placed _B. orientalis_ and _B. germanica_ together,
there were no reciprocal attacks even by hungry individuals. Wille
concluded that because of their greater speed, smaller size, greater
number of eggs, and faster development, the German cockroaches eat the
available food and so make the environment unfavorable for the oriental.
However, he noted that cases may be seen in which the opposite is also
possible. Laing (1946; British Museum [Natural History], 1951) observed
that in the British Isles _B. orientalis_ seems to have lost its
dominant position to _B. germanica_ in recent years; it was stated that
these species are not as a rule found together and that the greater
rapidity of breeding and ability to climb of _B. germanica_, as well as
the layout of modern buildings, are some of the factors that favor the
spread of _B. germanica_. Ledoux (1945) found that first-instar nymphs
of _B. germanica_ and fourth-instar nymphs of _B. orientalis_, adults of
_B. germanica_ and sixth-instar nymphs of _B. orientalis_, as well as
adults of both species, did not form mixed groups. However, when he
combined fifth-and sixth-instar nymphs of _B. germanica_ with
fourth-and fifth-instar nymphs of _B. orientalis_, which are all
practically of equal size, sometimes he would find mixed groups, but
generally the groups were distinct. Lucas (1912) stated that Burr had
found _B. germanica_ and _B. orientalis_ swarming within a rubbish heap
in England; presumably both colonies were breeding and multiplying and
one species was not detrimental to the presence of the other.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account