_Answer._--It is perfectly true that there is a threefold ministry
mentioned in these Epistles. But there is no sufficient reason for
denying that such a ministry is of apostolic origin. It seems quite
certain that at Jerusalem the presbyters and deacons were under the
authority of St. James, and after his death under that of Symeon. The
same form of government can also be traced back in other places to
apostolic times. Moreover, the organization which is mentioned in Acts
is fundamentally the same as that in these Epistles. In Acts we {199}
find the apostles first appointing deacons and then presbyters. All
the additional evidence which has lately been discovered to support the
genuineness of Acts therefore favours the genuineness of these
Epistles. Finally, we must notice that the titles of the ministry in
these Epistles do not correspond with the titles used in the 2nd
century. The government is substantially "Episcopal," but the title
"episkopos" was in the 2nd century only applied to the chief dignitary
who ruled over the "presbyters." But here the title "episkopos" is
applied to the presbyters themselves as the overseers of the
congregation. We find the same thing in the letter of St. Clement,
A.D. 95. St. Clement, although Bishop of Rome, still gives the title
of "episkopos" to the presbyters. This inconvenient practice was given
up soon after that date, for we find that St. Ignatius, about A.D. 110,
applies the title "episkopos" only to the highest ministers of the
Church. We conclude, therefore, that while the organization of the
Church described in the Pastoral Epistles supports the belief that the
threefold ministry, which we now call Episcopal organization, is of
apostolic origin, it does not prove that these Epistles are forgeries.
And it is natural that St. Paul, knowing that his death must before
long come to pass, should devote a large measure of attention to
questions of Church government and discipline. The history of the
Church in the 2nd and 3rd centuries proves to us that the organization
of the Church was almost as important as the inspiration of the Church.
4. _Language._--This is an important difficulty. There are in these
Epistles many words and phrases which do not occur in the other
Epistles of St. Paul. We find different Greek words used for "Lord"
and for the second "advent," and a fondness for the words "wholesome,"
"godliness," and "faithful saying." The new element is most prominent
in 1 Tim. and Titus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account