The Brass Check: A Study of American JournalismSinclair, Upton
General
The Brass Check: A Study of American Journalism
Sinclair, Upton
Associated Press; Journalism -- United States; Press -- United States
And so next morning there was an editorial in the “Times,” of which I
will quote about half. You will be struck by its peculiar style, and may
be interested to know that it was written by General Otis himself, being
a fair sample of the vitriol which every day for thirty years he poured
out upon everything enlightened in California:
UPTON SINCLAIR’S RAVINGS
Many people believe that the prattlings of an anarchistic Upton
Sinclair before a woman’s club are unworthy of serious attention; but
the fact that the hall of the Friday Morning Club was filled to
overflowing at his programme, and that the great majority of them sat
throughout the entire lecture, would seem to prove that such illogical
ravings have at least some power to impress. Some few women have been
found courageous enough to voice their indignation that the club
rostrum should be used for such ungodly purposes.
It is depressing to find a great number of intelligent women, well
able to think for themselves, lending time and ear to a piffling
collection of more-or-less brilliant quotations upholding anarchy,
destruction, lawlessness, revolution, from the lips of an effeminate
young man with a fatuous smile, a weak chin and a sloping forehead,
talking in a false treble, and accusing them of leading selfish,
self-indulgent lives. It would be laughable if it were not a little
disconcerting. These women, who are doing such earnest work for their
city, who, indeed, rank among the best intellect of the city, who have
deeds rather than words to their credit—it seems incredible that they
should be prepared to lend encouragement to such unintelligent,
witless, anarchistic outpourings.
While slyly veiling his false doctrines as quotations from
“intelligent ancient peasants,” and the prophet Isaiah, and the Greek
classics, Upton Sinclair nevertheless makes no secret of his sympathy
with dynamiters and murderers, and considers it an example of
exquisite wit to speak of Jesus Christ with patronizing irreverence.
His sense of humor also demanded that he belittle the flag of the
United States, and, after pretending to confuse it with a barber’s
pole scoff at the great national wave of emotion for the country’s
righteous defense and honor.
An assembly of men of the same standing as the women of the Friday
Morning Club could never be induced to listen to such insults to their
creed and their country without violent protest. Never before an
audience of red-blooded men could Upton Sinclair have voiced his weak,
pernicious, vicious doctrines. His naïve, fatuous smile alone would
have aroused their ire before he opened his vainglorious mouth.
Let the fact remain that this slim, beflanneled example of perverted
masculinity could and did get several hundred women to listen to him.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account