The Camel and the Needle's EyePonsonby, Arthur Ponsonby, Baron
Philosophy
The Camel and the Needle's Eye
Ponsonby, Arthur Ponsonby, Baron
Wealth; Wealth -- Moral and ethical aspects
There is, we must confess, a recurring note in modern thought, the
constant use of which is amounting almost to a popular mannerism. It
is a method of reasoning which inclines men to spurn deep convictions
or strong single-minded purpose as clumsy, uncouth, and unphilosophic,
and to welcome in their place involved generalisations and a spirit of
abstract compromise and theoretical balancing. Whether this tends to a
more profound acquisition of knowledge and a more exact and scientific
adjustment of mental conceptions, is not for us to say, but that it
casts a weakening spell over personal initiative and greatly impedes
decisive action is clear beyond doubt.
As for the Church, it is failing in its mission, because it refuses to
insist equally on the two aspects of the message it has undertaken to
deliver to mankind.
If religion is received in a purely dogmatic sense, it can appeal only
to our emotions and to the spiritual cravings of the more mystical
side of men’s natures. This is only confusing and quite unsatisfying
to our more rationalistic inclinations, which prefer a simple and
direct ethical teaching. Christianity combines the two elements--the
mystical and the rational--and fuses them together. Unfortunately
there is a proneness to detach the former as all-important and
sufficient in itself and to neglect the latter. The former has been
built up gradually in successive centuries of varying and imaginative
speculation, and however much it may appeal to the religious-minded,
it is valueless when broken off from the latter. The ethical precepts
for duty and conduct are, on the other hand, immutable, and in their
pristine simplicity carry all their original force of authority and
lose nothing from being divorced from dogmatic teaching. It requires no
heights of spiritual exaltation to accept Christ’s explicit precepts
as to sacrifice, humility, altruism, and the renunciation of worldly
possessions, but men are encouraged by the Church to seek consolation
in a fog of doctrinal obscurantism. Christ no doubt foresaw that we
should take refuge in the incomprehensible in our failure to accept
what to the humblest intelligence was perfectly comprehensible when he
said, “Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into
the Kingdom of Heaven, but he that doeth the will of my Father which is
in Heaven.”
His immediate successors were not handicapped by considerations for or
subservience to those in authority who held the worldly power, and they
spoke with no uncertain voice.
What is wanted in the Church to-day is something of the uncompromising
spirit of those bygone days. Not condonation, or at the most
half-hearted criticism, but wholesale denunciation in words of splendid
vehemence such as the passage in the Epistle of St. James:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account