The Case for Birth Control: A Supplementary Brief and Statement of FactsSanger, Margaret
Science
The Case for Birth Control: A Supplementary Brief and Statement of Facts
Sanger, Margaret
Birth control; Eugenics
In the face of these figures and the suffering, misery and
disappointment of parents who lose their children after having tenderly
loved and cared for them for some years, I wonder if there can be any
doubt in the minds of sane men that it would have been better if these
children had never been born. Surely all this is race suicide instead of
race preservation.
Not so very long ago I was asked by a young colleague to aid in the
diagnosis of tuberculosis in a day laborer. The man earned $12 a week,
was thirty-six years of age on the day the examination and diagnosis was
made, had been married fourteen years, and his eleventh child had been
born on his last birthday; four or five had already died, two of them of
tuberculous meningitis. A glance at the rest of the family showed that
nearly all of them were predisposed to tuberculosis, if not already
infected, and that a few years of continued underfeeding and bad housing
would finish their earthly career. With two or three children to provide
for the family might have lived in relative comfort; with better food
and better home environments the father might never have become
tuberculous and none of the children might have contracted the disease.
The commonwealth would have been the gainer by two or three mentally and
physically vigorous future citizens.
Only a few days ago, while an article for the _Journal of Sociologic
Medicine_ was in preparation, an Italian woman presented herself to me
for examination. She gave her age as fifty-six, and had married quite
young. She had borne her husband seventeen children, of which, however,
only four were living. Some had died in infancy, some at school age, and
some during adolescence. What useless suffering! What useless economic
loss to the individual family and society at large. Upon examination, I
found the woman’s mental condition even worse than her physical status.
The repeated pregnancies, the frequent diseases in the family, thirteen
deaths among her children, had made a mental and physical wreck of her.
Yet the woman belonged to the better and well-to-do class of our
population of Italian birth. What would her condition have been if she
had also had to share in the struggle for the existence of the family,
and had had to work in sweatshops or factories, as so many of the poor
Italians have to do?
When pregnancy means danger to the life of the mother, or exacerbation
of an existant mental or physical ailment, as, for example,
tuberculosis, which is always aggravated by child-bearing, every
conscientious physician should do his utmost to prevent childbirth in
such an invalid.
Where there is tuberculosis or any other serious transmissible disease
in one or both of the parents, or there is danger that it may be
transmitted to the offspring, it should not only be the right but the
sacred duty of the physician to prevent the conception of any physically
and mentally handicapped offspring destined to become a burden to the
community.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account