I can absolutely assure you that these photographs were taken under strictest test conditions in my home and in the presence of seven reliable witnesses who are willing to attest to their genuineness. I myself bought the plates, etc., and was the only one who handled them until they were developed, which was keenly watched by all. Mr. Hope never actually touched the plates. They are fine photographs of Mr. W. J. Cary, Mr. Geo. Dove, of whom there is no normal photo in existence, and Mrs. Catton. I can quite well assure you that they caused quite a sensation in Sutton-in-Ashfield where all of them were well known. (_Signed_) CHARLES DOVE. _Homelea, Oak Tree Road, Sutton-in-Ashfield._ * * * * * The Evidence of MRS. A. ELIZABETH GRIERE, OF DUNFERMLINE (_The likenesses of father and husband were obtained on one photograph, the features of the latter being clearer than those of the sitter. This photograph is shewn by fig. 26. Fig. 27 reproduced alongside gives a normal photograph of Mr. Griere for comparison._) I have great pleasure in forwarding the enclosed pictures. My sitting with Mr. Hope took place in December of 1921. I brought my own plates as directed, and I wish to state that throughout the whole proceedings Mr. Hope did not handle these plates unless to load the camera out in the studio. I took them out of the wrapper, placed them in the slide, unloaded and developed them. The result of the sitting you have before you. I am perfectly satisfied that the “extra” on No. 1 picture is the face of my husband, and on No. 2 the “extras” are those of my husband and my father. You will see the undoubted resemblance to the original photograph herewith enclosed. _I was a total stranger to Mr. Hope and his good friend, Mrs. Buxton_, and I shall always remain indebted to them both for their courtesy during my visit to Crewe. I trust this picture may be of some use to you. (_Signed_) A. ELIZABETH GRIERE. _20, Woodmill Road, Dunfermline._ * * * * * The Evidence of E. W. LEE, ESQ., OF SHANKLIN, ISLE OF WIGHT I am enclosing four photographs, one normal and three psychographs. [Not reproduced.—ED.] All the psychographs were taken in Crewe. Our first meeting was arranged through the post. We were quite strangers and had no mutual acquaintances likely to be in touch with each other. I live in the Isle of Wight; Mr. Hope in Crewe. The photograph obtained on the first occasion bears the strongest likeness to my dear wife. The whole operations, less the fixing of the slide in the camera and making the exposure, were undertaken by myself. Although I had not the slightest reason to suspect Mr. Hope, I treated him by my actions as a man open to swindle his patrons.