The Catholic World, Vol. 01, April to September, 1865: A Monthly Eclectic MagazineVarious
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 01, April to September, 1865: A Monthly Eclectic Magazine
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
"Human organogeny is a comparative transitory anatomy, as
comparative anatomy is the fixed and permanent state of the
organogeny of man; and, on the contrary, if we reverse the
proposition, or method of investigation, and study animal life from
the lowest to the highest, instead of considering it from the
highest to the lowest, we shall see that the organisms of the series
reproduce incessantly those of the embryos, and fix themselves in
that state which for animals becomes the term of their development.
The long series of changes of form presented by the same organism in
comparative anatomy is but the reproduction of the numerous series
of transformations to which this organism is subjected in the embryo
in the course of its development. In the embryo the passage is
rapid, in virtue of the power of the life which animates it; in the
animal the life of the organism is exhausted, and it stops there,
because it is not permitted to follow the course traced for the
human embryo. Distinct stages on the one hand, progressive advance
on the other, here is the secret of development, the fundamental
difference which the human mind can perceive between comparative
anatomy and organogeny. The animal series thus considered in its
organisms is but a long chain of embryos which succeed each other
gradually and at intervals, reaching at last man, who thus finds his
physical development in comparative organogeny."
Thus speaks Serres. And in another place:
"The whole animal kingdom appears only like one animal in the course
of formation in the different organisms. It stops here sooner, there
later, and thus at the time of each interruption determines, by the
state in which it then is, the distinctive and organized characters
of classes, families, genera, and species."
II.
THIS OPINION REFUTED BY PHILOSOPHICAL REASONS.
The futility of the above doctrine is manifest, in the first place,
from the weakness of the foundation on which it rests. That foundation
is no other than a kind of likeness which appears at first sight
between the rudimental forms which, in the first steps of its
development, are assumed by the human embryo, and the forms of some
inferior animals. For the germ, by the very reason that it has not, as
it was once believed, all the organism of the human body in
microscopic proportions, but in order to acquire it must pass from
potential to actual existence--by that very reason, is {73} subjected
to continual metamorphoses, that is, to successive transformations,
which give it different aspects, from that of a little disc to the
perfect human figure. Now, it is clear that, in this gradual
transition from the mere power to the act of perfect organization, a
kind of analogy or likeness to some of the numberless forms of
inferior organizations of the animal kingdom may, and must, be found
in its intermediate and incomplete state.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account