The Catholic World, Vol. 07, April 1868 to September, 1868Various
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 07, April 1868 to September, 1868
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
"If a man speaks thus, after a careful study of Cousin, it is
almost useless to argue with him. He either has not understood
the philosopher, or his scepticism is hopelessly obstinate.
Intuition, as asserted by Cousin, is not reduced to its proper
character, but simply misrepresented, when it is called
empirical; for it is the primitive mode of reason, and prior to
all experience. It is a revelation of the objective to the
subject, and to be a revelation must, of course, come into the
consciousness of the subject. Cousin has carefully and
repeatedly established the true character of intuition as a
disclosure to the understanding in the reason, and free from
any touch of subjectivity. _Of course, his ontological
conclusions rest on a belief in the credibility of reason, and,
of course, this credibility can never be established in a
logical way, although, metaphysically, it is abundantly
established_. One may 'assume,' to the end of time, that 'to
the operation of reason no objective reality is necessary,
since the object may, for aught that appears, be included in
the subject,' but the universal and invincible opinion of the
human race has been, and will be, to the contrary of such an
assumption.
"As firmly as Reid and Hamilton have established the doctrine
of sensible perception, and the objective existence of the
material world, has Cousin that of the objective existence of
the absolute, and, on the very same ground, the veracity of
consciousness. And the mass of mankind have lived in happy
ignorance of any necessity for such arguments. When they sowed
and reaped, and bought and sold, they never questioned the real
existence of the objects they dealt with; _nor did they, when
the idea of duty or obligation made itself felt in their souls,
dream that, 'for such an operation of reason, no objective
reality was necessary_.'
"Men have an unquestioning but unconquerable belief, that the
very idea of obligation implies _something outside of
them_, that obliges. Something other than itself it must be,
that commands the soul. Right is a reality, and duty a fact.
The philosophy, that does not come round to an enlightened and
intelligent holding of the unreflecting belief of mankind, but
separates itself from it, is worse than useless. In such wisdom
it is indeed 'folly to be wise.' And this philosophic folly
comes from insisting on a logical demonstration of what is
logically undemonstrable--of what is superior, because anterior
to reasoning. We cannot _prove_ to the understanding
truths which are the very basis and groundwork of that
understanding itself." (Pp. 536, 537.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account