The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and ScienceVarious
Religion
The Catholic World, Vol. 17, April, 1873 to September, 1873: A Monthly Magazine of General Literature and Science
Various
Catholic Church -- Periodicals
2. “That often, in adjacent islands, we find animals closely resembling
and appearing to represent each other; while, if certain of these
islands show signs of more ancient separation, the animals inhabiting
them exhibit a corresponding divergence.
3. That “‘rudimentary structures’ also receive an explanation by means
of this theory.
4. “That the singular facts of ‘homology’ are capable of a similar
explanation.”
5. That “that remarkable series of changes which animals undergo before
they attain their adult condition, which is called their process of
development, and during which they more or less closely resemble other
animals during the early stages of the same process, has also great
light thrown on it from the same source.”
6. That “by this theory, and as yet by this alone, can any explanation
be given of that extraordinary phenomenon which is metaphorically
termed ‘mimicry.’”
To explain in detail the exact import of each of these heads would
carry us beyond the limits of a magazine article; and the reader who
wishes for more minute and definite information on them we must refer
to Mivart’s own book, or to Darwin’s _Origin of Species_.
Pass we now to those facts which Darwin’s theory is incompetent to
explain, and to the arguments against it. Mr. Mivart enumerates them
thus:
1. “That ‘natural’ selection is incompetent to account for the
incipient stages of useful structures.
2. “That it does not harmonize with the coexistence of closely similar
structures of diverse origin.
3. “That there are grounds for thinking that specific differences may
be developed suddenly instead of gradually.
4. “That the opinion that species have definite though very different
limits to their variability is still tenable.
5. “That certain fossil transitional forms are absent which might have
been expected to be present.
6. “That some facts of geographical distribution supplement other
difficulties.
7. “That the objection drawn from the physiological difference between
‘species’ and ‘races’ still exists unrefuted.”
Our readers will readily understand that, if species, or rather
individual animals, were originated by natural law, and if that law be
“natural selection,” the action of “natural selection” must be able
to explain not only the production of the animal as a whole, but of
its several organs, both when they have reached the point of maximum
utility, and at all stages previous thereto.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account