The censorship of the Church of Rome and its influence upon the production and distribution of literature, volume 1 (of 2)Putnam, George Haven
History
The censorship of the Church of Rome and its influence upon the production and distribution of literature, volume 1 (of 2)
Putnam, George Haven
Freedom of the press; Liberty of conscience; Prohibited books
The first name in the list of expurgated authors is that of Arias
Montanus. Montanus had himself borne the chief responsibility in the
production of the Index issued in Antwerp in 1546. He had been accepted
as an authority not only for sound scholarship, but for sound doctrine.
About six pages of the Roman Index are devoted to his writings, which
here suffer a castigation and mutilation similar to that formerly
inflicted by him on other authors.
Space is given (as in all the expurgatory Indexes) to the Bibles of
Robert Estienne. The longest and most important article in the volume
is that devoted to the _Bibliotheca SS. Patrum_ of La Bigne printed in
Paris in 1589. As an example of the class of correction found necessary
in the _Bibliotheca_ may be noted the correction of cancellation of
_Sanctus_ or _Sanctorum_ or _S. Divus_ or _D._ whenever such term is
applied to a personage not in the list of Roman saints or of Roman
martyrs. The words _Caute lege_ appear frequently in connection with
the text of La Bigne. On page 82, Clemens of Alexandria is degraded
from the rank of _Divus_. In the critique upon S. Peter Martyr, Bishop
of Alexandria, the censor denounces his commentator, Balsamon, as “a
Greek and a schismatic.” S. Chromatius is censored as condemning oaths
altogether. S. Ignatius is censored for his opinions respecting the
Lord’s Day. Leontius is censored for omitting the apocryphal books
in the canon. La Bigne is censored for ascribing the work _De Duabus
Naturis_ to Gelasius who became Pope. Jonas Aurelianensis is censored
for his testimony against image worship. Marcus the hermit is censored
for contending that the kingdom of heaven is not given as a reward
for our good works. For Paschasius the title of _Divus_ is ordered
to be expunged. He is further censored for describing as creation
the change of the elements. Photius, Bishop of Constantinople, is
condemned (very naturally) for representing his own see as the head
of all the churches. To the Spanish author, Emmanuel Sa, is given a
discipline or censorship covering twenty-eight pages. In the next
succeeding Spanish Index, Sa is acquitted of any false or erroneous
doctrine and his writings are held up to special approbation. It was
with the Roman criticism of Sa that originated a long series of issues
between the Index makers of Rome and those of Spain. Francis Duarenus
received a castigation, which he might fairly have expected, for his
work _Pro libertate Ecclesiae Gallicae_, in section 77 of which are
detailed the heavy exactions of the Papal See. Cardanus is condemned
for his _Eulogy_ of Edward VI. A condemnation is also brought in upon
Queen Elizabeth, the text for the same being a dedication to the Queen
prefixed to a London edition of _Plato_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account