The censorship of the Church of Rome and its influence upon the production and distribution of literature, volume 2 (of 2)Putnam, George Haven
History
The censorship of the Church of Rome and its influence upon the production and distribution of literature, volume 2 (of 2)
Putnam, George Haven
Freedom of the press; Liberty of conscience; Prohibited books
This was the time in which the battle of
Jena was being fought and one might perhaps suppose that the attention
of the Emperor would have been sufficiently engaged with affairs in
Germany.
Under the imperial censorship, occurred instances of expurgations
which recall the expurgatory Indexes of the Spanish Inquisition. In
the _Athalie_ of Racine, before a new edition was permitted to be
printed, certain passages had to be cancelled because they contained
allusions to “tyranny.” Chénier had permitted himself in his drama
_Cyrus_ to present the following lines:
“_Je ne commande point, j’obéis à la loi;
Et je suis à l’État, l’État n’est point à moi._”
These lines had to be cancelled before the performance of the play was
permitted.[65] Kotzebue’s _Souvenir d’un Voyage_ was prohibited because
the author had permitted himself certain favourable references to the
late Queen of Naples and to the English Admiral, Sidney Smith (“that
pirate,” said Napoleon). Madame de Staël’s _Corinne_ was prohibited in
1807 and a bitter criticism of the work, printed in the _Moniteur_, is
ascribed to the pen of Napoleon himself. Chateaubriand’s _Les Martyrs_
was, before being published, severely handled by the censors. After
suffering a large amount of elimination, it was brought into print,
but even then proved unacceptable and was prohibited. A reference to
the court of Diocletian was held by the police to constitute a _lèse
Majesté_. In November, 1809, Napoleon specified as the responsibilities
of censorship, _Le droit d’empêcher la manifestation d’idées qui
troublent la paix de l’État, ses intérêts et le bon ordre_. In the
same year, Napoleon says: _Qu’on laisse donc écrire librement sur la
religion, pourvu qu’on n’abuse pas de cette liberté pour écrire contre
l’État_.[66] In 1810, the Emperor instituted the post of _directeur
general de l’imprimerie et de la librairie_, with Portalis as the first
incumbent. The system of inspection and repression established under
this bureau continued until the close of the empire and was, in fact,
renewed with no great change after the return of the Bourbons.
Peignot, writing in 1806, during the “strenuous” years of the First
Empire and at a time when political censorship in France and in
the great territories outside of France that were under Napoleonic
control was most severe, is prepared to speak with full measure of
respect of the importance and the necessity of censorship. He finds
ground for criticism, however, in the cases in which the Roman Church
has undertaken to interfere with the control over French literature
which properly belonged to the bishops and to the civil government of
France, but he is quite prepared to accept the judgments of the Church
in regard to pernicious books provided that these judgments are kept
subordinated to the authority of the State.
Peignot speaks of “the happy Europe of his time” (the Europe controlled
by Napoleon),
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account