The Child in the Midst: A Comparative Study of Child Welfare in Christian and Non-Christian LandsPlatt, Mary Schauffler
Religion
The Child in the Midst: A Comparative Study of Child Welfare in Christian and Non-Christian Lands
Platt, Mary Schauffler
Church work with children; Missions
The eagerness of these gentlemen in discussing the question with
me, to find a place for their worthies in the ample folds of
Christian teaching is far from unwholesome or blameworthy,
especially when there is such readiness as they showed to appeal
to Christian teaching rather than to the sages as their standard,
and to prove the greatness of their sages by their agreement with
the Christ....
My purpose, however, is not to give an exposition of these
classical gems, but rather to contrast them briefly with certain
popular Chinese conceptions of childhood which are foolish or
cruel, but which these lofty sayings of the sages have been
powerless to correct.
Should a child fall ill, his relatives or friends very likely
remark, “His spirit has gone seeking another incarnation.” Or
some one suggests, “Some ghost has frightened the child to the
point of losing its soul.”... Should the child die, the parents
will grieve as surely and as sorely as parents any where; but ...
they will be told, “Never mind, the child was misguided to your
home, and was not intended for you.” Or, “It was only a creditor
collecting a debt you owed in a former existence.” Or, “Don’t
grieve, it was but one of those demon spirits that always die
young.”...
I put these popular sayings beside the exalted sentiments of the
Chinese Classics, not to disparage the sages, but to show how
utterly dark the popular mind is, in spite of these sayings which
seem so full of light. Is not the difficulty that the sages after
all could not go to the root of the matter? They knew nothing of
God as Father.[81]
[Sidenote: Failure to influence lives for righteousness.]
What is here illustrated of the failure of Confucianism to influence
lives toward righteousness and faith is true of the other
non-Christian religions. Even the young Mohammedan girl realized the
power and claim of Christianity as she was a chance listener to the
Gospel story while a missionary toured in central Persia. “Why,
lady,” she exclaimed, “if one understands clearly that Book, there is
nothing left but to obey!”
The direct results of the way children are taught to worship in
non-Christian lands deserve careful, unprejudiced study, with the
question constantly in mind, “Is this religion good enough for _my_
children, or for those in whom I am interested?” If the study results
in a negative answer to the question, it is fair to ask further, “Is
it good enough for _any_ children in the whole wide world?”
[Sidenote: Result to the child of religious acts.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account