The Church, the Falling Away, and the RestorationShepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Religion
The Church, the Falling Away, and the Restoration
Shepherd, J. W. (James Walton)
Churches of Christ -- Doctrines; Disciples of Christ -- Controversial literature; Disciples of Christ -- Doctrines
The movement to put these exhortations into practice began first among
the clergy. Two priests in parishes near Wittenberg married; several
monks left their cloisters and donned the garments of the common people;
Melanchthon and several of his students “communicated in both kinds in
the church,” and his example was followed by others. Images were
condemned and cast out of the churches. No one knew what would next be
done, and disturbing rumors were being circulated. Carlstadt now took
the lead and announced that on the first day of the new year he would
“celebrate the Lord’s Supper after the ancient manner in both kinds.
When opposition threatened he anticipated the time and held the service
on Christmas day. A beginning was made; opposition was silenced and
Carlstadt had his way.”
Things were going too fast for the Elector Frederick, too fast for
Luther. In his quiet retreat in Wartburg he wrote against the mass and
monkish vows, “but how great a step there is between condemning old
customs in our hearts and changing them with our hands—between the
thoughts and the act!” On being informed of the reformatory movements in
Wittenberg, Luther resented it, and most sharply reproved them for
practicing what he had preached. In a letter written to the
Wittenbergers in December, 1521, he said:
They have introduced changes in the mass and images, attacked the
sacrament and other things that are of no account, and have let love
and faith go; just as though all the world hereabouts had great
understanding in these matters, which is not the fact; and so many
have brought it about that many pious people have been stirred up to
do what is really the devil’s work. It would, indeed, be a good thing
to begin such changes, if we could all together have the needful
faith; and if they suited the church in such measure that no one could
take offense at them. But this can never be. We can not all be as
Carlstadt. Therefore we must yield to the weak; otherwise those who
are strong will run far, and the weak who can not follow them at like
pace will be run down.
It was not by Luther, but by men of a different type, that this
practical work was begun. There was sore need for a Zwilling and a
Carlstadt. This was an occasion when those who were called fanatics did
a real service for mankind. They were strong in their convictions, saw
only one thing, reckless of all consequences, and brave where other men
are appalled, and with no misgivings kindled a fire that wrapped the
world in flame. Had it not been for what they did, “Luther’s writing and
preaching might have ended in preaching and writing. They saw that
something must be done, and they did it!” While this was needful in
precipitating the conflict, it was equally necessary that others should
direct it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account